#musicbrainz

/

      • lauri
        so you really need to show all three
      • 2008-03-02 06225, 2008

      • stochasticism joined the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06225, 2008

      • RaiseHell joined the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06217, 2008

      • RaiseHell
        hi. I've a quick question: I created two new artists, one being a person, the other one being a group. I want to create a relationship where the person founded the group, but I can't seem to find the location where to do that
      • 2008-03-02 06241, 2008

      • Freso
        RaiseHell: There isn't one. Add it in the annotation.
      • 2008-03-02 06249, 2008

      • RaiseHell
        oh, ok, thanks very much
      • 2008-03-02 06247, 2008

      • yllona
        isn't there a founded by AR?
      • 2008-03-02 06230, 2008

      • lauri
        only for labels i think
      • 2008-03-02 06238, 2008

      • luks_
        luks_ is now known as luks
      • 2008-03-02 06259, 2008

      • RaiseHell
        yep, I've used it for a label yesterday
      • 2008-03-02 06226, 2008

      • RaiseHell
        that's why I was sure there's the same possibility to relate a person as a founder to a group
      • 2008-03-02 06227, 2008

      • lauri
        i normally just use the 'is a member of' and don't set the start date
      • 2008-03-02 06255, 2008

      • RaiseHell
        ah, ok, that's another possiblity, thanks
      • 2008-03-02 06210, 2008

      • lauri
        which doesn't leave it clear between "I don't know the start date" and "was a founder member", but hopefully implies the latter
      • 2008-03-02 06212, 2008

      • RaiseHell
        I'll use both an annotation and the "member of ..."
      • 2008-03-02 06220, 2008

      • lauri
        and annotations are never bad
      • 2008-03-02 06228, 2008

      • RaiseHell
        right, thanks :-)
      • 2008-03-02 06201, 2008

      • creature has left the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06244, 2008

      • lauri
        yo brian
      • 2008-03-02 06212, 2008

      • lauri
        or any other classical editors
      • 2008-03-02 06225, 2008

      • BrianFreudf has quit
      • 2008-03-02 06235, 2008

      • BrianFreudf joined the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06238, 2008

      • lauri
        oh look, i broke him
      • 2008-03-02 06248, 2008

      • lauri
        brian, you feel like a wee job?
      • 2008-03-02 06223, 2008

      • HairMetalAddict has quit
      • 2008-03-02 06236, 2008

      • HairMetalAddict joined the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06201, 2008

      • Amberrock joined the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06213, 2008

      • Amberrock has left the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06248, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        whatcha need lauri?
      • 2008-03-02 06208, 2008

      • lauri
        oh you are gonna love it
      • 2008-03-02 06210, 2008

      • lauri
      • 2008-03-02 06246, 2008

      • lauri
        could you at least help me figure out what the heck it's called?
      • 2008-03-02 06226, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        ooh, pretty
      • 2008-03-02 06211, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        I don't know the particular work - Beethoven's Fideleo I assume?
      • 2008-03-02 06222, 2008

      • lauri
        well, i think that's the intention
      • 2008-03-02 06234, 2008

      • yllona
        it's fidelio
      • 2008-03-02 06235, 2008

      • lauri
        also, i presume there is a disc 2 or more floating around, but i didn't find it yet
      • 2008-03-02 06242, 2008

      • lauri
        lord only knows what artist that one's under
      • 2008-03-02 06210, 2008

      • yllona
        cristoph von dohnanyi conducting
      • 2008-03-02 06250, 2008

      • yllona
        wiener philharmonic,
      • 2008-03-02 06251, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        Fideleo (feat. Wiener Philharmoniker, conductor: Christoph von Dohnányi) (disc 2)
      • 2008-03-02 06259, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        oops, disc 1
      • 2008-03-02 06200, 2008

      • yllona
        \
      • 2008-03-02 06219, 2008

      • lauri
        ahh, that's what i was after (and move it all to beethoven, right?)
      • 2008-03-02 06227, 2008

      • lauri
        if it isn't a dupe, which it might be
      • 2008-03-02 06239, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        yep
      • 2008-03-02 06256, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        do you have the recording lauri, or just cleaning it up?
      • 2008-03-02 06203, 2008

      • Freso has quit
      • 2008-03-02 06209, 2008

      • lauri
        no, i just spotted the bogus artist entry and took a peep
      • 2008-03-02 06219, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        ahh. if you have times for cd 2, faux's search might help you find it
      • 2008-03-02 06231, 2008

      • lauri
        and then after my eyes stop bleeding, i thought i'd ask for help
      • 2008-03-02 06233, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        lol
      • 2008-03-02 06246, 2008

      • yllona
        i think theat recording was two opera in a set
      • 2008-03-02 06211, 2008

      • lauri
        so the other disc might be a completely different opera, with a completely different bogus artist? oh neat
      • 2008-03-02 06213, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        yeah, running similar searches based on picard lookups myself, trying to find misplaced Philips Mozart box releases
      • 2008-03-02 06244, 2008

      • lauri
        i was actually looking for "CD 2" of something else heh, and found this instead
      • 2008-03-02 06204, 2008

      • yllona
      • 2008-03-02 06257, 2008

      • lauri
        well that's interesting, amazon 404's on that link
      • 2008-03-02 06210, 2008

      • yllona
        my bad
      • 2008-03-02 06213, 2008

      • yllona
      • 2008-03-02 06219, 2008

      • lauri
        basically the entire internet is hating on me today
      • 2008-03-02 06233, 2008

      • lauri
        the wiki wouldn't let me edt it either :)
      • 2008-03-02 06239, 2008

      • BrianFreudf spots this one and sighs... http://musicbrainz.org/album/54c30714-c58c-4ada-b83c-cfceb3e9dc77.html?tport=8000
      • 2008-03-02 06257, 2008

      • lauri
        ooooohkay, what the heck do i call that then, since i now can't call it fidelio
      • 2008-03-02 06214, 2008

      • lauri
        how about i make the artist beethoven, put the asin, and hope someone who actually has it finds it?
      • 2008-03-02 06234, 2008

      • yllona
        i'd call it Fidelio / Lenore
      • 2008-03-02 06240, 2008

      • yllona
        it is a box set
      • 2008-03-02 06203, 2008

      • lauri
        a 4 disc one... yow
      • 2008-03-02 06209, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        Lenore / Fideleo (feat. Wiener Philharmoniker, conductor: Christoph von Dohnányi) (disc 1: Fideleo)
      • 2008-03-02 06214, 2008

      • lauri
        thank you :)
      • 2008-03-02 06245, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        (though I misspelled Leonore)
      • 2008-03-02 06210, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        ah... one other thing I notice lauri
      • 2008-03-02 06223, 2008

      • lauri
        hmm?
      • 2008-03-02 06233, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        It's a Brilliant Classics release - it's quite likely part of the BC Beethoven box cooperaa
      • 2008-03-02 06236, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        is entering
      • 2008-03-02 06200, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        they like to re-release each bit like this after they release the uber-boxes
      • 2008-03-02 06203, 2008

      • lauri
        oh well, hopefully he'll spot it then, it's still in the queue
      • 2008-03-02 06230, 2008

      • cooperaa
        hm?
      • 2008-03-02 06233, 2008

      • lauri
        it's got trm's (even though it's new!) so it may be worth merging
      • 2008-03-02 06238, 2008

      • lauri
        and there he is
      • 2008-03-02 06250, 2008

      • RaiseHell has left the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06222, 2008

      • lauri
      • 2008-03-02 06235, 2008

      • cooperaa
        *sigh*
      • 2008-03-02 06241, 2008

      • cooperaa
        Rockquiem?
      • 2008-03-02 06247, 2008

      • lauri
        hey, check the edit history before you sigh heh
      • 2008-03-02 06201, 2008

      • lauri
        this is the vastly improved by yllona and brian version
      • 2008-03-02 06205, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
      • 2008-03-02 06213, 2008

      • cooperaa
        okay good, I thought you were going to say I added it in my MB infancy
      • 2008-03-02 06220, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        oh, lol, same release :P
      • 2008-03-02 06240, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        no, but the one she found is prob part of the BC Beethoven box
      • 2008-03-02 06240, 2008

      • lauri
        ahah, no, it's a new addition, but it may be a dupe of stuff you're working on already
      • 2008-03-02 06203, 2008

      • cooperaa
        I've actually tried to save that stuff for last (worst for last)
      • 2008-03-02 06214, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        lol, sounds like me with the Philips operas
      • 2008-03-02 06217, 2008

      • cooperaa
        because I don't have much experience with them and the overtures always mess me up
      • 2008-03-02 06238, 2008

      • cooperaa
        (I don't think I have Fidelio in http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/CSGStandard/Beethoven yet)
      • 2008-03-02 06253, 2008

      • lauri
        oh i doubt you could have messed this one up worse, even if you added 'made famous by wool advertising'
      • 2008-03-02 06201, 2008

      • cooperaa
        and there's a whole story behind Fidelio... originally title Leonore and renamed and revised and multiple versions :(
      • 2008-03-02 06207, 2008

      • cooperaa
        lol
      • 2008-03-02 06220, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        lol, then this gets better, since the 4 CDs include both Leonore and Fideleo :P
      • 2008-03-02 06228, 2008

      • lauri
        well, that explains the 4 disc set, and the weird naming
      • 2008-03-02 06235, 2008

      • cooperaa
        :P
      • 2008-03-02 06256, 2008

      • lauri
        now i forgot what i was searching for when i found that in the first place heh
      • 2008-03-02 06200, 2008

      • cooperaa
        that is an amazing release title though: "; Ruth Ziesak; Uwe Heilmann; Wiener Philharmoniker; Christoph von Dohnányi / Ludwig van Beethoven -- Fideleo -- (CD 1)"
      • 2008-03-02 06211, 2008

      • yllona
        but both are performed independently at this stage they are considered two separate operas
      • 2008-03-02 06215, 2008

      • lauri
        oh especially in combo with the artist it was filed under :)
      • 2008-03-02 06222, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        looks like the ".../Requiem" title I found a little while ago today
      • 2008-03-02 06224, 2008

      • cooperaa
        hahahaa
      • 2008-03-02 06244, 2008

      • lauri
        and as i said... it implies there's 3 other discs of it floating around (who adds trm's for one disc of a box set?)
      • 2008-03-02 06249, 2008

      • cooperaa
        someone filed a release under "Beethoven (complete)" the other day... I put in a merge.. please go vote yes on it ;)
      • 2008-03-02 06257, 2008

      • lauri
        looks like it already went through
      • 2008-03-02 06203, 2008

      • cooperaa
        k good
      • 2008-03-02 06215, 2008

      • cooperaa
        back to studying for me... I'll keep that release open
      • 2008-03-02 06228, 2008

      • cooperaa
        will do
      • 2008-03-02 06233, 2008

      • cooperaa
        later
      • 2008-03-02 06238, 2008

      • lauri
        heh
      • 2008-03-02 06244, 2008

      • lauri
        it's all yours now, i have done all the damage i can
      • 2008-03-02 06248, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        lol, if you want the other similar messes, http://musicbrainz.org/mod/search/results.html?mo…
      • 2008-03-02 06214, 2008

      • BrianFreudf
        all Beethoven cooperaas
      • 2008-03-02 06235, 2008

      • hangy has quit
      • 2008-03-02 06236, 2008

      • lauri_ joined the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06224, 2008

      • lauri__ joined the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06205, 2008

      • BrianG
        i made a booboo, can i get some love? http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=8403539
      • 2008-03-02 06211, 2008

      • yllona
        BrianG: done
      • 2008-03-02 06239, 2008

      • BrianG
        thank you!
      • 2008-03-02 06218, 2008

      • Freso joined the channel
      • 2008-03-02 06208, 2008

      • outsidecontext
        anybody some experience with japanese releases?
      • 2008-03-02 06256, 2008

      • lauri has quit
      • 2008-03-02 06251, 2008

      • lauri__
        depends on the question outsidecontext
      • 2008-03-02 06201, 2008

      • lauri__
        but i do have a teenage daughter with an anime obsession :)
      • 2008-03-02 06216, 2008

      • outsidecontext
        :)
      • 2008-03-02 06219, 2008

      • outsidecontext
      • 2008-03-02 06239, 2008

      • outsidecontext
        is " ※JANコード:45 71139 01013 1" the barcode?
      • 2008-03-02 06241, 2008

      • lauri__
        and she conveniently just arrived home too!
      • 2008-03-02 06200, 2008

      • lauri_ has quit
      • 2008-03-02 06214, 2008

      • outsidecontext
        oh, that question was probably to heavy
      • 2008-03-02 06228, 2008

      • lauri__
        easiest way to tell that is plug it into the ean database lookup heh
      • 2008-03-02 06246, 2008

      • luks
        the release editor will tell you if it isn't
      • 2008-03-02 06248, 2008

      • warp
        outsidecontext: JAN is the equivalent of EAN and er.. UPC?
      • 2008-03-02 06253, 2008

      • lauri__
      • 2008-03-02 06257, 2008

      • luks
        but yes, JANs are compatible with EANs
      • 2008-03-02 06201, 2008

      • warp
        outsidecontext: so, yes.
      • 2008-03-02 06203, 2008

      • lauri__
        it usually works on all kinds
      • 2008-03-02 06206, 2008

      • outsidecontext
        lauri: MB did accept it
      • 2008-03-02 06210, 2008

      • lauri__
        there's another one, but i don't seem to have it bookmarked
      • 2008-03-02 06213, 2008

      • outsidecontext
        warp: thanks
      • 2008-03-02 06230, 2008

      • warp back from .de
      • 2008-03-02 06233, 2008

      • lauri__
        and i'm still sorta stunned by that cover
      • 2008-03-02 06238, 2008

      • lauri__
        it's wrong in so very many ways :)
      • 2008-03-02 06247, 2008

      • lauri__
        photo, whatever heh
      • 2008-03-02 06253, 2008

      • outsidecontext
        lauri: which cover