#musicbrainz

/

      • Shepard kicks the server
      • 2005-08-24 23612, 2005

      • orogor has quit
      • 2005-08-24 23658, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: yeah someone is obviously playing hard on the servers ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23601, 2005

      • fuchs
      • 2005-08-24 23620, 2005

      • Shepard
        not me :o *looks innocent*
      • 2005-08-24 23618, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: i doubt you could request a 1,500 trms a minute over hours ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23633, 2005

      • Shepard
        You are currently subscribed to these 153 artists. - i wonder if i some day might get near to mo
      • 2005-08-24 23659, 2005

      • fuchs
        is there a way to sort the subscribe list?
      • 2005-08-24 23626, 2005

      • Shepard
        sort?
      • 2005-08-24 23641, 2005

      • fuchs
        even with my few subscriptions I always subscribe more than once to an artist ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23606, 2005

      • Shepard
        more than once??
      • 2005-08-24 23624, 2005

      • fuchs
        yes, i click subscribe when i'm already subscribed :)
      • 2005-08-24 23636, 2005

      • Shepard
        well that changes nothing
      • 2005-08-24 23645, 2005

      • fuchs
        it's anoying :)
      • 2005-08-24 23654, 2005

      • dholmes
        You can sort them.. by copying and pasting them into some other tool that sorts :P
      • 2005-08-24 23602, 2005

      • fuchs
      • 2005-08-24 23631, 2005

      • Shepard
        you mean the subscribe link should vanish or turn into an unsubscribe link when you are subscribed?
      • 2005-08-24 23619, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: no i just want to see the subscription list sorted to figure out with one short view wether I'm subscribed to one artist or not :)
      • 2005-08-24 23634, 2005

      • Shepard
        hm.. mine is sorted
      • 2005-08-24 23603, 2005

      • Shepard
        exept that it doesn't sorte umlaute the german way but under the alphabet
      • 2005-08-24 23606, 2005

      • fuchs
        ehm - oops, yeah, forget what i said *dumdidum*
      • 2005-08-24 23617, 2005

      • fuchs
        I'm just blind that's it ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23626, 2005

      • Shepard
        hehe
      • 2005-08-24 23646, 2005

      • fuchs
        i'm always confused by the sortname sorting :)
      • 2005-08-24 23606, 2005

      • Shepard
        you're not the first one :)
      • 2005-08-24 23615, 2005

      • fuchs
        hmm, so Die Ärzte should have Die Aerzte as sortname, shouldn't it?
      • 2005-08-24 23627, 2005

      • fuchs
        ehm Aerzte, Die i mean
      • 2005-08-24 23612, 2005

      • Shepard
        well the curious thing is, this sorting algorithm is only applied to the subscription list. in the artist search you'll find it sorted like we would expect it
      • 2005-08-24 23635, 2005

      • fuchs
        hmm
      • 2005-08-24 23618, 2005

      • Shepard
        and you don't want to change all umlaute in the sortnames, do you? :)
      • 2005-08-24 23647, 2005

      • Shepard
        (or umlauts would be correct english plural)
      • 2005-08-24 23655, 2005

      • fuchs
        no, it would be enough to change every appearance of the artistname to it's sortname :)
      • 2005-08-24 23620, 2005

      • Shepard
        hä?
      • 2005-08-24 23630, 2005

      • fuchs
        just kidding :)
      • 2005-08-24 23629, 2005

      • fuchs
        *calling interpol to find the guy flooding the servers*
      • 2005-08-24 23614, 2005

      • Shepard
        if that isn't the same one flooding Bavaria
      • 2005-08-24 23649, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: what's the normal way of naming an album, that has Limited Edition or Special Edition printed on the cover as some kind of a subtitle?
      • 2005-08-24 23657, 2005

      • fuchs
        who cares about bavaria?
      • 2005-08-24 23600, 2005

      • Daedalus joined the channel
      • 2005-08-24 23617, 2005

      • Shepard
        at the moment: leaving that out
      • 2005-08-24 23646, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: http://musicbrainz.org/showmod.html?modid=3265124 <- so this is a "no" to the album title?
      • 2005-08-24 23604, 2005

      • Shepard
        though you might find some moderators agreeing with you if you put it in *doesn't tell names* ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23637, 2005

      • fuchs
        yeah i voted "yes" on at least one of those myself
      • 2005-08-24 23605, 2005

      • Shepard
        well I wouldn't vote no on this because the title is wrong
      • 2005-08-24 23616, 2005

      • Shepard
        as one could change it easily
      • 2005-08-24 23628, 2005

      • fuchs
        http://musicbrainz.org/showartist.html?artistid=1… <- it would have been bet to have yet another Hot Fuss ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23640, 2005

      • fuchs
        s/bet/bad/
      • 2005-08-24 23604, 2005

      • Shepard
        i can understand if we don't keep it because arguing if it's really a subtitle is sometimes hard. comparing http://images-eu.amazon.com/images/P/B00005J8ZX.0… and http://images-eu.amazon.com/images/P/B00005B3QD.0… it is easy but mostly they keep the cover as it is and only put a small sticker on it
      • 2005-08-24 23604, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: what do you plan on doing with max raabe and the orchestra mess
      • 2005-08-24 23604, 2005

      • Shepard
        saying something like "limited edition XXX pieces" and the album is nearly the same
      • 2005-08-24 23625, 2005

      • Shepard
        nothing *g*
      • 2005-08-24 23635, 2005

      • fuchs
        why not?
      • 2005-08-24 23643, 2005

      • Shepard
        it's just "zum kotzen"
      • 2005-08-24 23659, 2005

      • Shepard
        and i don't know how to deal with it
      • 2005-08-24 23615, 2005

      • fuchs
        just put everything under max raabe, the orchestra isa unimportant :)
      • 2005-08-24 23626, 2005

      • Shepard
        if you look under amazon you find thousands of ways they write the name
      • 2005-08-24 23644, 2005

      • Shepard
        well but the orchestra also exists as a separate artist
      • 2005-08-24 23655, 2005

      • fuchs
        fine, then link it in
      • 2005-08-24 23601, 2005

      • Shepard
        and i don't know if he sung on all of the albums
      • 2005-08-24 23635, 2005

      • fuchs
        if he didn't he wouldn't appear as part of the artist, would he?
      • 2005-08-24 23659, 2005

      • Shepard
        http://images-eu.amazon.com/images/P/B0001ZWL7E.0… <- here the palast orchester looks more important
      • 2005-08-24 23616, 2005

      • Shepard
      • 2005-08-24 23612, 2005

      • Shepard
        he is just part of the orchester
      • 2005-08-24 23640, 2005

      • fuchs
        but he's the known part and the name those cds are sorted under in cd stores :)
      • 2005-08-24 23606, 2005

      • dholmes
      • 2005-08-24 23608, 2005

      • Shepard
        at least no cover on amazon says "_Das_ Palast Orchester" so i can change that
      • 2005-08-24 23640, 2005

      • fuchs
      • 2005-08-24 23649, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: but you are right, especially the older releases list the Palastorchester very prominently on the title
      • 2005-08-24 23627, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: those are from the time when he wasn't as famous as he is now
      • 2005-08-24 23606, 2005

      • fuchs
        dholmes: i can't read a word of this mod :)
      • 2005-08-24 23603, 2005

      • dholmes
        fuchs, it's an album of four tracks, two of which are arrangements of tracks by other composers
      • 2005-08-24 23655, 2005

      • dholmes
        Both arrangements are fairly direct renditions of the originals, and the second is just a synthesized version of a classical song
      • 2005-08-24 23616, 2005

      • fuchs
        yeah yeah, i voted already ,)⇧
      • 2005-08-24 23659, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: but is it Palastorchester or Palast Orchester?
      • 2005-08-24 23610, 2005

      • Shepard
        most covers have it splitted
      • 2005-08-24 23618, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: so I would make it "Palast Orchester & Max Raabe" as the main artist name, and add a few hundred aliases for all the other possible names :)
      • 2005-08-24 23646, 2005

      • Shepard
        and put all albums there?
      • 2005-08-24 23613, 2005

      • fuchs
        all that have both listed on the front cover :)
      • 2005-08-24 23638, 2005

      • fuchs
        it's odd :(
      • 2005-08-24 23643, 2005

      • fuchs
        "Die Dreigroschenoper" not, f.e.
      • 2005-08-24 23608, 2005

      • Shepard
        I'm unsure..
      • 2005-08-24 23648, 2005

      • fuchs
        i had similar problems where the artist was called something like "Nationalchor der DDR und Orchester der Nationalen Volksarmee" or similar :)
      • 2005-08-24 23653, 2005

      • Shepard
        well on collaborations you normally have "Person & Group" but here the person is a member of the group so I think "Group & Person" is ok
      • 2005-08-24 23622, 2005

      • fuchs
        but is he really a member? an orchestra normally doesn't have a singer
      • 2005-08-24 23606, 2005

      • Shepard
        then this is the name of the whole act
      • 2005-08-24 23612, 2005

      • fuchs
        what does discogs with this?
      • 2005-08-24 23621, 2005

      • Shepard
        doesn't have it? :)
      • 2005-08-24 23627, 2005

      • fuchs
        well great :)
      • 2005-08-24 23640, 2005

      • fuchs
        nobody cares about german music *crying* ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23652, 2005

      • Shepard
        well they mostly care about electronic music
      • 2005-08-24 23623, 2005

      • Shepard
        I'm always happy if they even know one of the most known metal bands
      • 2005-08-24 23603, 2005

      • fuchs
        and wikipedia?
      • 2005-08-24 23638, 2005

      • fuchs
        Max Raabe (* Dezember 1962 in Lünen) ist ein bekannter deutscher Sänger sowie Gründer und Leiter des Palast Orchesters.
      • 2005-08-24 23645, 2005

      • fuchs
        aha
      • 2005-08-24 23650, 2005

      • fuchs
        so he is part
      • 2005-08-24 23600, 2005

      • Shepard
        yeah
      • 2005-08-24 23645, 2005

      • Shepard
        i had the same today with Orson Welles & The Mercury Theatre (he founded it together with another person)
      • 2005-08-24 23649, 2005

      • fuchs
        so "Palast Orchester & Max Raabe" would be like Metallica & Lars Ullrich
      • 2005-08-24 23621, 2005

      • Shepard
        yes but also we have *searches*
      • 2005-08-24 23646, 2005

      • fuchs
        you could add Max Raabe as an alias for Palast Orchester :)
      • 2005-08-24 23607, 2005

      • fuchs
        but I'm not sure people would like tagging there files with Palast Orchester only ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23614, 2005

      • Shepard
        mwah.. how was she called.. a singer who was part of a band but we keep "singer & band" too
      • 2005-08-24 23633, 2005

      • fuchs
        nena :)
      • 2005-08-24 23652, 2005

      • fuchs
        udo lindenberg ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23657, 2005

      • Shepard
        nono this is clear.. there the band is called Nena and the member Nena Kerner
      • 2005-08-24 23628, 2005

      • Shepard
        english artist *tries to remember*
      • 2005-08-24 23635, 2005

      • Shepard
        head -> table
      • 2005-08-24 23604, 2005

      • fuchs
        hammer -> sheppy's back-head
      • 2005-08-24 23605, 2005

      • Shepard
        Diana Ross and The Supremes
      • 2005-08-24 23629, 2005

      • Shepard
      • 2005-08-24 23625, 2005

      • Shepard
        i tried to merge this into the supremes but people didn't agree
      • 2005-08-24 23638, 2005

      • fuchs
        :)
      • 2005-08-24 23606, 2005

      • fuchs
        so we also could move everything to artist "[unknown]" :)
      • 2005-08-24 23634, 2005

      • fuchs
        or even beter VA and link every member of the orchestra in :)
      • 2005-08-24 23653, 2005

      • Shepard
        yeah this would solve all our problems
      • 2005-08-24 23606, 2005

      • fuchs
        not the searching
      • 2005-08-24 23633, 2005

      • Shepard
        or we could give up trying to do mb correct... and turning our backs on mb and forget it forever
      • 2005-08-24 23641, 2005

      • Shepard
        and we all would be happy :)
      • 2005-08-24 23651, 2005

      • Shepard
        but wait.. what to do with our mp3s?
      • 2005-08-24 23600, 2005

      • fuchs
        not an option i have some untagged oggs ;)
      • 2005-08-24 23603, 2005

      • fuchs
        yeah
      • 2005-08-24 23629, 2005

      • Shepard
        ok.. so if we take Diana Ross and The Supremes as a precedent case
      • 2005-08-24 23649, 2005

      • Shepard
        then Max Raabe & Palast Orchester would do it?
      • 2005-08-24 23638, 2005

      • fuchs
        sortname: Palast Orchester & Max Raabe - just to make sure people are really confused :)
      • 2005-08-24 23611, 2005

      • Shepard
        waaahh x_X
      • 2005-08-24 23604, 2005

      • fuchs
        oh he really has some releases of his own http://www.musicline.de/de/artist/Raabe%2CMax%A5I…
      • 2005-08-24 23612, 2005

      • Shepard
        i have to make a lists of all variants on the covers and then evaluate them statistical
      • 2005-08-24 23648, 2005

      • Shepard
        SurvivalOfTheFittest
      • 2005-08-24 23655, 2005

      • fuchs
        :)
      • 2005-08-24 23615, 2005

      • fuchs
        i think Max Raabe & Palast Orchester is the best, it's used on current releases and everybody will find what she's looking for
      • 2005-08-24 23650, 2005

      • Shepard
        and since he is member of the orchestra it's not a collaboration so Palast Orchester should be merged into it
      • 2005-08-24 23630, 2005

      • Shepard
        if they ever do something without him it's not the full orchestra and should have another name
      • 2005-08-24 23644, 2005

      • Shepard
        *not the full act
      • 2005-08-24 23613, 2005

      • fuchs
        Shepard: the first volume of a series is normally not names "Volume 1". Do we add it nevertheless?
      • 2005-08-24 23621, 2005

      • fuchs
        -s+d
      • 2005-08-24 23631, 2005

      • Shepard
        depends on how it's written on the cover
      • 2005-08-24 23637, 2005

      • Shepard
        some series have it
      • 2005-08-24 23621, 2005

      • fuchs
        k
      • 2005-08-24 23620, 2005

      • Shepard
        though sometimes for long series we don't care a lot on what is written on the cover for consistency. Café del Mar for example
      • 2005-08-24 23623, 2005

      • Quiky joined the channel
      • 2005-08-24 23635, 2005

      • Shepard
      • 2005-08-24 23640, 2005

      • Shepard
        so i can do the final step
      • 2005-08-24 23645, 2005

      • Quiky
        There you go.
      • 2005-08-24 23623, 2005

      • Shepard
        thanks :)
      • 2005-08-24 23641, 2005

      • Shepard
        fuchs: if you want you can do the fine tuning in the albums :P
      • 2005-08-24 23647, 2005

      • Shepard
        *on
      • 2005-08-24 23607, 2005

      • fuchs
        *looking around* nice weather it is :)
      • 2005-08-24 23600, 2005

      • Shepard
        dark it is
      • 2005-08-24 23614, 2005

      • Shepard
        yoda speech we do
      • 2005-08-24 23612, 2005

      • Quiky
        Cats be shot, tresspassers are they.