#musicbrainz

/

      • aron_kexp has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30319, 2015

      • zas has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30327, 2015

      • Nyanko-sensei has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30358, 2015

      • legoktm is now known as legoktm[NE]
      • 2015-10-30 30331, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        might be a simple question, but how do i add a DVD Video to a CD release?
      • 2015-10-30 30337, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        anyone?
      • 2015-10-30 30349, 2015

      • Nyanko-sensei joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30309, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        rctgamer3: do you mean that there's a second disc (a dvd)?
      • 2015-10-30 30328, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        or that there's a video data track on a CD?
      • 2015-10-30 30342, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        CallerNo6: Yes, it's a CD+DVD release, with the DVD containing the video clips of the CD
      • 2015-10-30 30305, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        ah, okay
      • 2015-10-30 30320, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        both in the same jewelcase
      • 2015-10-30 30355, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        have you added a second disc ("medium") to a release before? that's the first step.
      • 2015-10-30 30348, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        you do that in the tracklist tab.
      • 2015-10-30 30310, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        I think someone added it for me afterwards, but i've never added a second medium myself - found the add disc option but didn't know where to start
      • 2015-10-30 30333, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        Oh, i did add one myself, just completely forgot how to
      • 2015-10-30 30358, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        It should be pretty straightforward. when you're editing a release, you add discs in the "tracklist" tab. for each disc ("medium") you can choose a different type ("CD", "Vinyl"etc)
      • 2015-10-30 30322, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        backing up a bit, are you adding a new release or editing an existing one?
      • 2015-10-30 30303, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        well, editing, but i just submitted/tagged the CD today so still adding the rest of the details
      • 2015-10-30 30315, 2015

      • matrixagent has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30330, 2015

      • aron_kexp joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30336, 2015

      • aron_kexp has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30300, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        CallerNo6: about to submit the edit, i suppose there isn't some kind of DVD identification thing for MB?
      • 2015-10-30 30328, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        you mean like discids or acoustids?
      • 2015-10-30 30333, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        yeah
      • 2015-10-30 30336, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        not that I know of
      • 2015-10-30 30325, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        but cool, sounds like everything went smoothly
      • 2015-10-30 30320, 2015

      • rctgamer3
      • 2015-10-30 30354, 2015

      • Freso
        rctgamer3: If you know of something outside of MB, let us know, and we can talk about supporting that. AFAIK there's nothing akin to DiscIDs for DVDs.
      • 2015-10-30 30329, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        quick second question: kara(oke) tracks without vocals, attribute to the artist of the identical track with vocals anyway?
      • 2015-10-30 30325, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        poke: CallerNo6 Freso
      • 2015-10-30 30318, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        is it the same recording but with vocals removed?
      • 2015-10-30 30340, 2015

      • rctgamer3
        yeah, it's a karaoke version
      • 2015-10-30 30351, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        right, I mean, it's not a sound-alike/cover.
      • 2015-10-30 30319, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        So the same band would be credited, yes. Ideally, you'd make a separate recording with disamgibuation comment "karaoke" and link it to the same work.
      • 2015-10-30 30337, 2015

      • CallerNo6 is having a moment of doubt. "wait, that's right isn't it"... looks for some documentation
      • 2015-10-30 30350, 2015

      • JonnyJD has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30354, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        nothing in the docs. I can't think of why the track artist would be anybody but the performers.
      • 2015-10-30 30359, 2015

      • Yurim has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30313, 2015

      • Jinx has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30350, 2015

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30334, 2015

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30324, 2015

      • MightyJay has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30335, 2015

      • RJ2 has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30314, 2015

      • dan6a_ has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30333, 2015

      • MightyJay joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30335, 2015

      • RustyB has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30344, 2015

      • RJ2 joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30307, 2015

      • mezod has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30311, 2015

      • Gore|home has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30346, 2015

      • Gore|home joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30340, 2015

      • dan6a_ joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30333, 2015

      • RustyB joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30310, 2015

      • legoktm[NE] is now known as legoktm
      • 2015-10-30 30340, 2015

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30311, 2015

      • JesseW joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30321, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        legoktm: shiny new mediawiki :-) What version did you upgrade /from/? (I'm trying to get a sense of what's changed - was the last upgrade the 2012 one mentioned in the blog?
      • 2015-10-30 30345, 2015

      • legoktm
        1.19.2 was the old version
      • 2015-10-30 30340, 2015

      • legoktm
        CallerNo6: https://wiki.musicbrainz.org/User:Legoktm/1.23 has links to all the release notes
      • 2015-10-30 30326, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        oh, nice. thanks.
      • 2015-10-30 30351, 2015

      • Gentlecat has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30303, 2015

      • CallerNo6
        huh, nothing earth-shattering then
      • 2015-10-30 30345, 2015

      • JesseW has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30326, 2015

      • hibiscuskazenek1 joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30311, 2015

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30322, 2015

      • JesseW joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30339, 2015

      • balrog has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30321, 2015

      • balrog joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30347, 2015

      • beat has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30338, 2015

      • beat joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30348, 2015

      • hibiscuskazenek1 has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30331, 2015

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30314, 2015

      • Freso has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30320, 2015

      • JoeLlama joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30311, 2015

      • Freso joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30305, 2015

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30330, 2015

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30331, 2015

      • hibiscuskazenek1 joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30306, 2015

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30301, 2015

      • hibiscuskazenek1 has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30341, 2015

      • ariscop has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30347, 2015

      • Gentlecat joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30322, 2015

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30314, 2015

      • JesseW has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30309, 2015

      • hibiscuskazenek1 joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30321, 2015

      • hibiscuskazenek1 has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30311, 2015

      • yeeeargh joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30354, 2015

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30332, 2015

      • d4rkie joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30310, 2015

      • Nyanko-sensei has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30342, 2015

      • simukis_ joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30313, 2015

      • zas joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30351, 2015

      • ariscop joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30330, 2015

      • snoozebrainz joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30352, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        what happens if you cancel an add release edit?
      • 2015-10-30 30359, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        case in question:
      • 2015-10-30 30302, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
      • 2015-10-30 30322, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        I added a cd with track times from the cover, but the track times on cd differ for the last track
      • 2015-10-30 30355, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        that tracktime makes it identical to an other release that I entered an edit to merge with
      • 2015-10-30 30308, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        but the recording used for track 6 is shared with some other recordings, so it shouldn't be merged
      • 2015-10-30 30331, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        so I'm wondering if canceling the add release edit will make it all good, or if I have to cancel the merge edit
      • 2015-10-30 30343, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        update the used recordings and then redo the merg?
      • 2015-10-30 30300, 2015

      • pankkake
        yeah, I think your last option is the best
      • 2015-10-30 30316, 2015

      • pankkake
        ping me when you do so I can approve the move (otherwise the merge will merge the wrong recordings)
      • 2015-10-30 30345, 2015

      • pankkake
        on another note cancelling the add release will simply make the following edits fail, so should be cancelled along
      • 2015-10-30 30307, 2015

      • Leftmost pictures pankkake nodding sharply in approval at the edit and having it go through.
      • 2015-10-30 30320, 2015

      • ruaok joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30313, 2015

      • Leftmost
        Generally I think it's probably best not to cancel add release edits, just as it's best to merge instead of delete.
      • 2015-10-30 30346, 2015

      • pankkake
        it's a less than 7 days old release, so, doesn't matter as much
      • 2015-10-30 30309, 2015

      • Leftmost
        No, but I'd still call it best practice.
      • 2015-10-30 30302, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        I know about the merge > delete :) that's why I tried to merge.. but I got to learn to make it properly :)
      • 2015-10-30 30313, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        pankkake: will ping you when I have made the recording change, thanks!
      • 2015-10-30 30324, 2015

      • zas has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30354, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
      • 2015-10-30 30356, 2015

      • zas joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30310, 2015

      • pankkake
        done!
      • 2015-10-30 30343, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        great, thanks!
      • 2015-10-30 30318, 2015

      • JoeLlama has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30346, 2015

      • d4rkie has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30312, 2015

      • Nyanko-sensei joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30338, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        can anyone check http://musicbrainz.org/edit/35707924 and see if it makes sense? would rather not make one more mistake :)
      • 2015-10-30 30343, 2015

      • zas
        snoozebrainz, as far i undestand it was made in Sweden but released in the US only ?
      • 2015-10-30 30304, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        to how I understand it
      • 2015-10-30 30310, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        that's is how even :)
      • 2015-10-30 30346, 2015

      • simukis_ has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30339, 2015

      • Yurim joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30303, 2015

      • jundar joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30358, 2015

      • jundar
        hi all, can someone give me a little advice on how to add a new release for this group: https://musicbrainz.org/release/024ea49b-9695-438…
      • 2015-10-30 30310, 2015

      • jundar
      • 2015-10-30 30351, 2015

      • Yurim
        Klick "Add release" at the right side of the screen?
      • 2015-10-30 30300, 2015

      • Gore|home has quit
      • 2015-10-30 30354, 2015

      • pankkake
        these look like scary releases (50 CDs…). you'd have to ask for more precise advice, but I can see why you'd ask!
      • 2015-10-30 30304, 2015

      • jundar
        Yup, worked hard on this one :)
      • 2015-10-30 30307, 2015

      • jundar
        Problem is: when I add another release based on this one, it doesn't add all tracks. The releases are identical apart from the publishing date, cover and barcode (simple stuff, really).
      • 2015-10-30 30321, 2015

      • jundar
        Even when I choose "based on existing release". Maybe musicbrainz can't handle this amount of data? :-)
      • 2015-10-30 30342, 2015

      • jundar
        (Can't wait to edit the 150CD Johann Sebastian Bach full works release that is sitting on my desk right now...)
      • 2015-10-30 30317, 2015

      • JonnyJD joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30321, 2015

      • pankkake
        I've tried the "release duplicates" tab and it worked, I have the 50 CDs
      • 2015-10-30 30357, 2015

      • snoozebrainz
        worked for me as well, but I needed to press the little arrow to show the tracks on teh different cds :)
      • 2015-10-30 30349, 2015

      • Leftmost
        jundar, don't forget to scan and clean up artwork for all of it!
      • 2015-10-30 30333, 2015

      • jundar
        Oookay, I'll try it again, thanks.
      • 2015-10-30 30329, 2015

      • jundar
        Artwork is only a big ugly box, thankfully. I'll get a scan, the single CD sleeves are not worth the hassle IMO
      • 2015-10-30 30352, 2015

      • kuno
        Leftmost: hm, I have full scans of the 2006 version of Brilliant Classics bach edition, but I never got around to entering all of that in MB.
      • 2015-10-30 30338, 2015

      • kuno
        jundar: in my case the CD sleeves have the tracklists, so I thought it was interesting enough to do a full scan.
      • 2015-10-30 30300, 2015

      • kuno
        jundar: which bach box do you have?
      • 2015-10-30 30325, 2015

      • achadwick joined the channel
      • 2015-10-30 30302, 2015

      • jundar
        barcode is 7619929117824, it's got a german and english title; seems to be the same as the "Classica d'Oro' release apart from the barcodes.
      • 2015-10-30 30338, 2015

      • jundar
        I'm missing 1 cd sleeve and 2 or 3 suffered beneath the hands of my son. For completeness' sake I shall scan them in time :)
      • 2015-10-30 30341, 2015

      • jundar
        kuno: provided I can still get some sleep I want to update and finish the Brilliant Bach release in the next weeks. But this is a metric buttload of stuff to do :)
      • 2015-10-30 30306, 2015

      • jundar
        kuno: perhaps we can collaborate on the cover scans for that one...