A little confused about a particular release title. I’m entering the data for the score for Z for Zachariah. Amazon calls it ‘Z For Zachariah - Original Motion Picture Soundtrack’. iTunes calls it ‘Z For Zachariah (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack)’. The label’s site has the two on separate lines with no punctuation in between. The cover shows ‘Original Motion Picture...
2016-01-01 00134, 2016
Aankhen``
...Soundtrack’ on...
2016-01-01 00136, 2016
Aankhen``
...the top left and ‘Z for Zachariah’ on the bottom right. What’s the best way to format it?
2016-01-01 00132, 2016
chirlu`
darwin: The difference between a bot and a userscript is that the userscript acts on the immediate supervision of the user.
If you have performer info, that'd be great, but that's unrelated
2016-01-01 00124, 2016
Yurim
I'm unsure about part titles ("Ode to Joy", "Spring from The Four Seasons"), numbers that are out of order ("Nocturne no. 2 in E-flat major, op. 9 no. 2" instead of "Nocturne in E-flat major, op. 9 no. 2"), and extra information ("Concerto for Violin in E major" instead of "Concerto in E major").
2016-01-01 00123, 2016
reosarevok
Well, whatever is printed
2016-01-01 00127, 2016
Yurim
I was just going over the recently added releases for various artists. In the past I avoided the classical releases, but a new year brings new challenges. :-)
2016-01-01 00143, 2016
reosarevok
Without having the release, I can't know whether those are fine, but I'm assuming they're printed probably
2016-01-01 00159, 2016
reosarevok
If so, they're fine - "new" CSG is much less strict
2016-01-01 00125, 2016
Yurim
The part title is written in two different ways: "Symphony no. 9: Finale. Presto - ‘Ode to Joy’" and "Concerto for Violin no. 1 in E major, op. 8 no. 1 RV 269 (‘Spring’ from The Four Seasons)". That's ok?
2016-01-01 00147, 2016
Yurim
Please ignore the single quotes for now.
2016-01-01 00137, 2016
reosarevok
Yeah, if that's how the release has it, that's fine
2016-01-01 00156, 2016
Yurim
... three, actually: "Peer Gynt-Suite no. 1, op. 46: In the Hall of the Mountain King"
2016-01-01 00108, 2016
reosarevok
(it's not that common to see multiple ways when it's both parts - but
2016-01-01 00113, 2016
reosarevok
That's the same as the Symphony ;)
2016-01-01 00136, 2016
reosarevok
But yeah, for example when a release includes a full work and a part, it's not that weird to have, say
2016-01-01 00154, 2016
reosarevok
"Sonata no. X: I. Allegro" and then "Finale (from Sonata no. Y)"
2016-01-01 00157, 2016
reosarevok
And that's fine :)
2016-01-01 00129, 2016
Yurim
Ok, thank you a bunch
2016-01-01 00103, 2016
reosarevok
But really, the most useful thing here would be performer info (especially for compilations like these, where it's the main chance of finding wtf each one is)
2016-01-01 00107, 2016
Yurim
Do I (or you) know enough about these recordings to link it to the works?
2016-01-01 00122, 2016
reosarevok
So if you feel like contacting new users about those, that's usually a good thing to mention :)
2016-01-01 00134, 2016
reosarevok
Hmm. Yeah, I think we do
2016-01-01 00147, 2016
reosarevok
But a lot of them need to be "partial recording of" because they're fragments or unspecified movements
(generally it's hard to find proper info for this kind of compilation without the disc)
2016-01-01 00128, 2016
reosarevok
I'm going to wash a huge pile of dishes now
2016-01-01 00151, 2016
reosarevok
But I will be back in a bit - maybe try to add the missing info and I'll check it up when I'm back :)
2016-01-01 00123, 2016
Yurim
Do that. I will try to edit it a little bit further. If you could just check it afterwards, that would be nice.
2016-01-01 00139, 2016
mezod has quit
2016-01-01 00111, 2016
bitmap joined the channel
2016-01-01 00157, 2016
mezod joined the channel
2016-01-01 00110, 2016
Yurim
reosarevok (when back): I added of the releationships from the ebay page (except "Palmer, Watts, Davies, Shirley-Quirk" on track 4). Should the emphasized performers ("Francois René Duchable (piano)", "Marieke Blankenstijn (violin)", ...) have a "solo" attribute?
2016-01-01 00145, 2016
reosarevok shrugs
2016-01-01 00115, 2016
reosarevok
Doesn't matter much
2016-01-01 00119, 2016
Yurim
ok.
2016-01-01 00151, 2016
reosarevok
Rels look fine - I think it's just editing the titles to add the work parts left, and then you can try to match to works
2016-01-01 00146, 2016
krono joined the channel
2016-01-01 00100, 2016
adhawkins has quit
2016-01-01 00102, 2016
adhawkins joined the channel
2016-01-01 00128, 2016
Aankhen`` has quit
2016-01-01 00115, 2016
bitmap has quit
2016-01-01 00140, 2016
Leo_Verto joined the channel
2016-01-01 00131, 2016
Yurim
reosarevok: I'm done. I was not able to identify the works for "Bizet - Carmen: Prélude" and "Pachelbel - Canon in D major for Strings and Continuo". Thanks for all your help.
2016-01-01 00153, 2016
Yurim
I'm now a little bit more confident to tackle the classical releases.
2016-01-01 00101, 2016
reosarevok
:)
2016-01-01 00120, 2016
reosarevok
The Canon should be "Canon and Fugue in D major: Canon" or something
2016-01-01 00126, 2016
reosarevok
I'll check
2016-01-01 00118, 2016
Yurim
I guess you are right, I just did not want to add relationships based on my poor guesses.
