#musicbrainz

/

      • CatQuest
        one thing i'm noticing on that atribute page, mediums can have ar's to up to 9
      • 2017-02-17 04820, 2017

      • CatQuest
        I noticed earlier but i forgot to ask about it
      • 2017-02-17 04839, 2017

      • reosarevok
      • 2017-02-17 04851, 2017

      • reosarevok
        The medium thing is a horrible hack
      • 2017-02-17 04857, 2017

      • CatQuest
        ikr?
      • 2017-02-17 04816, 2017

      • reosarevok
        (I skipped the assignee bit because it's in a secondary page they don't even need to touch)
      • 2017-02-17 04820, 2017

      • kepstin has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04841, 2017

      • kepstin joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04843, 2017

      • reosarevok
        But yeah, the medium thing was a hack to migrate pre-NGS stuff
      • 2017-02-17 04824, 2017

      • reosarevok
        Nothing on the vocals bit, no, that still needs me to talk it through with bitmap at some point when we both have time to think about it
      • 2017-02-17 04834, 2017

      • CatQuest
        ok :)
      • 2017-02-17 04839, 2017

      • CatQuest
        and yes: that looks alright
      • 2017-02-17 04850, 2017

      • reosarevok
        Yay
      • 2017-02-17 04800, 2017

      • CatQuest
        we should ask CallerNo6 whne he's on what he thinks to add do it, since he's good with that
      • 2017-02-17 04819, 2017

      • CatQuest
        maybe also SothoTalKer?
      • 2017-02-17 04832, 2017

      • CatQuest
        he had good input with Quesito yesterday :D
      • 2017-02-17 04834, 2017

      • reosarevok
        Sure, it's a wiki, anyone can improve it :)
      • 2017-02-17 04849, 2017

      • CatQuest
        yea, but i'm intentionally pinging thme all so that they'll see it ;)
      • 2017-02-17 04855, 2017

      • reosarevok
        It's clear enough now I think that it's ok to have it up, but nothing against improving it further
      • 2017-02-17 04803, 2017

      • CatQuest
        yep
      • 2017-02-17 04815, 2017

      • CatQuest
        thanks for clearing out the messed up formatting
      • 2017-02-17 04818, 2017

      • reosarevok
        np!
      • 2017-02-17 04850, 2017

      • CatQuest
        (I also wanted all that stuff in, since I can't really demand that peopel add tickets with "this and that type" if it doesnt even say anywhere waht logic i'm using :o)
      • 2017-02-17 04827, 2017

      • CatQuest
        oh, oh, but maybe the part about the components.. was that removed or do you feel it's non-important?
      • 2017-02-17 04805, 2017

      • reosarevok
        It's there!
      • 2017-02-17 04807, 2017

      • reosarevok
        :)
      • 2017-02-17 04818, 2017

      • reosarevok
        Between Summary and Description, like in Jira itself
      • 2017-02-17 04819, 2017

      • CatQuest
        oh ho?
      • 2017-02-17 04829, 2017

      • CatQuest hasto re-read it again
      • 2017-02-17 04814, 2017

      • simukis__ has left the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04831, 2017

      • simukis__ joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04845, 2017

      • agentsim joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04811, 2017

      • CatQuest
        I'm sorry i can't see any info about "component" on https://wiki.musicbrainz.org/Instrument_List
      • 2017-02-17 04805, 2017

      • CatQuest
        oh wait there it is
      • 2017-02-17 04818, 2017

      • CatQuest
        thnaks reosarevok
      • 2017-02-17 04853, 2017

      • reosarevok
        np :)
      • 2017-02-17 04806, 2017

      • reosarevok
        loujine: any magic to remove "Concerto" from the movements on https://musicbrainz.org/artist/6b07e499-da41-4a93… ?
      • 2017-02-17 04852, 2017

      • Nyanko-sensei has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04820, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04844, 2017

      • dseomn has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04831, 2017

      • dseomn joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04855, 2017

      • JoeLlama has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04851, 2017

      • dseomn has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04836, 2017

      • simukis__ has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04838, 2017

      • simukis__ joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04826, 2017

      • dseomn joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04829, 2017

      • SothoTalKer
        CatQuest: you mentioned me? <3
      • 2017-02-17 04857, 2017

      • CatQuest
        ^^read up
      • 2017-02-17 04858, 2017

      • CatQuest
        :D
      • 2017-02-17 04819, 2017

      • tungol has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04811, 2017

      • SothoTalKer
        CatQuest some kind of wiki thing
      • 2017-02-17 04811, 2017

      • tungol joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04844, 2017

      • CallerNo6
        best or worst rom-com idea I've heard all day
      • 2017-02-17 04803, 2017

      • timbl has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04804, 2017

      • timbl joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04854, 2017

      • loujine
        reosarevok: I'll take a look, but I'm pretty sure I already did it once
      • 2017-02-17 04833, 2017

      • dseomn has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04857, 2017

      • timbl has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04854, 2017

      • dseomn joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04828, 2017

      • timbl joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04857, 2017

      • dseomn has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04842, 2017

      • timbl_ joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04804, 2017

      • timbl has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04806, 2017

      • Slurpee joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04831, 2017

      • dseomn joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04834, 2017

      • Freso
        reosarevok CatQuest, maybe Instrument Tree should just be changed to a redirect to https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Instrument ? And that page could have a section on how to request adding new ones?
      • 2017-02-17 04817, 2017

      • achadwick has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04818, 2017

      • CatCat
        Freso: sure
      • 2017-02-17 04827, 2017

      • tungol has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04832, 2017

      • Freso
        I think /doc/Entity pages are kind of semi-official, so let's get reosarevok to sign-off too, just to be safe. :)
      • 2017-02-17 04847, 2017

      • tungol joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04858, 2017

      • Freso
        And then I'll merge the contents and make/fix redirects.
      • 2017-02-17 04814, 2017

      • reosarevok
        Freso: good enough for me
      • 2017-02-17 04812, 2017

      • Freso
        Alright then. 👍 :)
      • 2017-02-17 04852, 2017

      • arbenina_ has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04823, 2017

      • CatQuest
        wait.. this mans some thing *I* basically wrote gets put (through a reosarevok-filter) into the official docs? :O
      • 2017-02-17 04853, 2017

      • CatQuest
        hvar det bra det som jeg skrev?
      • 2017-02-17 04806, 2017

      • Zastai joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04832, 2017

      • CatQuest
        hmm. is there a list of all the instruments.. https://beta.musicbrainz.org/instrument/
      • 2017-02-17 04834, 2017

      • CatQuest
        like?
      • 2017-02-17 04847, 2017

      • CatQuest
        i miss a "browse" for some enteties actually
      • 2017-02-17 04803, 2017

      • reosarevok
        Yes, it's in the documentation menu
      • 2017-02-17 04813, 2017

      • l3u joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04814, 2017

      • l3u
        Hi :-) I'm about to fix a quite messed up CD of a small band, would somebody please vote for edit #43659988 so that I can edit on?
      • 2017-02-17 04826, 2017

      • CatQuest
        if you link it maybe?
      • 2017-02-17 04808, 2017

      • l3u
        Oh sorry, wait a second
      • 2017-02-17 04829, 2017

      • CatQuest
        :)
      • 2017-02-17 04839, 2017

      • l3u
      • 2017-02-17 04827, 2017

      • Freso
        CatQuest: There was a GSoC... 2015? project that implemented a "browse" interface, but it never made it into MBS/master. :(
      • 2017-02-17 04840, 2017

      • Freso
        I think bitmap plans to brush it off and get it implemented.
      • 2017-02-17 04833, 2017

      • CatQuest
        right, for future reference l3u, it's good always to leave an edit note to explain/link sources for the change
      • 2017-02-17 04856, 2017

      • l3u
        Okay
      • 2017-02-17 04803, 2017

      • CatQuest
        Freso: :O that'd be so awesome
      • 2017-02-17 04832, 2017

      • CatQuest
        l3u: like, I don't know if you're changing this to "ep" becasue the band calls it a n ep or if you thikn it shoudl be for some oher reason :)
      • 2017-02-17 04803, 2017

      • l3u
        I simply chose the wrong release type, I added this one a second before, so I forgot to add a comment
      • 2017-02-17 04834, 2017

      • CatQuest
        ep is kinda "if it says so on the tin or if the band says it is"
      • 2017-02-17 04840, 2017

      • CatQuest
        aha!
      • 2017-02-17 04841, 2017

      • l3u
        But changes that are accepted automatically can't apparently be canceled
      • 2017-02-17 04843, 2017

      • CatQuest
        that's a good edit note
      • 2017-02-17 04858, 2017

      • l3u
        Otherwise, I would have deleted it and re-entered it correctly again
      • 2017-02-17 04810, 2017

      • CatQuest
        don't cancel your addition of the release, just edit it! :)
      • 2017-02-17 04837, 2017

      • CatQuest
        mb doesn't require everything ot be "perfect first time"
      • 2017-02-17 04813, 2017

      • CatQuest
        our philosophy is "some data is better than no data" and "no data is better thna wrong data" and "this is supposed ot be fun"
      • 2017-02-17 04815, 2017

      • CatQuest
        did i get that right CallerNo6 ?
      • 2017-02-17 04830, 2017

      • CatQuest
        except for typoes ¬¬
      • 2017-02-17 04833, 2017

      • CatQuest
        ugh
      • 2017-02-17 04810, 2017

      • zas
        You got it right ;)
      • 2017-02-17 04814, 2017

      • CatQuest
        ah l3u ha been her for 7 years already :O
      • 2017-02-17 04816, 2017

      • arbenina_ joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04821, 2017

      • CatQuest
        :D
      • 2017-02-17 04835, 2017

      • l3u
        But without too much editing
      • 2017-02-17 04845, 2017

      • CatQuest
        yes, but that's ok
      • 2017-02-17 04854, 2017

      • CallerNo6
        Oh. One of the rules is that you should do too much editing.
      • 2017-02-17 04802, 2017

      • CallerNo6 should write that down somewhere.
      • 2017-02-17 04807, 2017

      • Slurpee has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04821, 2017

      • matoro has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04833, 2017

      • CatQuest
        CallerNo6: but this is supposed to be fun!
      • 2017-02-17 04853, 2017

      • CallerNo6
        Not *too much* fun though!
      • 2017-02-17 04858, 2017

      • CallerNo6
        Well, maybe.
      • 2017-02-17 04833, 2017

      • CatQuest
        right.. if I wanted to do a search for instruments that had a description or disambiguation or tag with the word "hybrid" what would i do?
      • 2017-02-17 04838, 2017

      • Slurpee joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04838, 2017

      • Slurpee has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04838, 2017

      • Slurpee joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04803, 2017

      • l3u
        CatQuest: So we now have 3 "yes" votes for https://musicbrainz.org/edit/43659988 , I thought this would be enough to apply it?
      • 2017-02-17 04820, 2017

      • CatQuest
        it will on he hour as that's whne modbot runs to aply thee things
      • 2017-02-17 04826, 2017

      • CatQuest
        these*
      • 2017-02-17 04838, 2017

      • l3u
        Ah okay
      • 2017-02-17 04856, 2017

      • l3u
        It's really a long time since I was active on musicbrainz for the last time ;-)
      • 2017-02-17 04831, 2017

      • SothoTalKer
        how long? :)
      • 2017-02-17 04856, 2017

      • SothoTalKer
        and welcome back :D
      • 2017-02-17 04830, 2017

      • l3u
        A few years
      • 2017-02-17 04851, 2017

      • l3u
        Like since 2008 or so ;-)
      • 2017-02-17 04847, 2017

      • matoro joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04857, 2017

      • CatQuest
        ah. soo much has changed!
      • 2017-02-17 04858, 2017

      • CatQuest
        welcome back !
      • 2017-02-17 04830, 2017

      • l3u
        :-)
      • 2017-02-17 04846, 2017

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04828, 2017

      • dgw has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04828, 2017

      • Toast joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04812, 2017

      • matoro has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04857, 2017

      • tungol has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04853, 2017

      • tungol joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04852, 2017

      • matoro joined the channel
      • 2017-02-17 04859, 2017

      • loujine
        reosarevok: I fixed the Concerto attributes
      • 2017-02-17 04841, 2017

      • CatQuest
        aww, look at this guy https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/2/23/Ze… he invented that instrument. he looks so proud like he's holding his baby :D
      • 2017-02-17 04842, 2017

      • CatQuest
        it's interesting, he named it cümbüş it means reverly or fun, so when all families had to take surnames in 1934, he took the name *from* he instrument (as opposed to giving the isntrument his name)
      • 2017-02-17 04818, 2017

      • l3u
        When there a two releases of the same band in the same year, but only the release year and the order is known (no month), how can I add the right order?
      • 2017-02-17 04824, 2017

      • timbl_ has quit
      • 2017-02-17 04813, 2017

      • l3u
        CatQuest, Freso, zas: Would you be so kind and also vote for https://musicbrainz.org/edit/43661801 , this is the unification of the release group I just added. The comment translates to "This is how it's written on the original CD".
      • 2017-02-17 04856, 2017

      • CatQuest
        :)