Freso: could you also approve https://musicbrainz.org/edit/47728121 please? i see you approved the medium/recording edits which changed the same thing, i forgot that RG edits are not listed in release edits, so this one was out of sight. thanks!
2017-09-09 25202, 2017
culinko
also any input on the edit release edit is welcome
2017-09-09 25238, 2017
hibiscuskazeneko has quit
2017-09-09 25222, 2017
JoeLlama joined the channel
2017-09-09 25202, 2017
culinko
ok so i think my edit should not fail now (though language and script are filled in)
2017-09-09 25208, 2017
culinko
because one of the edits was reverted (which i missed)
2017-09-09 25239, 2017
culinko
so it seems like the editor changed the AC with autoedits before they saw my open edits (which should also not happen)
2017-09-09 25225, 2017
arbenina joined the channel
2017-09-09 25240, 2017
culinko
so at least i know it was not a deliberate attempt to make my edit fail
for the future: linking a few of those stores in the edit note is a good idea
2017-09-09 25256, 2017
culinko
i thought the edit is a nobrainer
2017-09-09 25202, 2017
CatQuest
nope :)
2017-09-09 25219, 2017
CatQuest
you're claiming that it's " feat. " exactly
2017-09-09 25224, 2017
culinko
and that if someone has problems with how it's displayed on the cover art, they would just let my edits pass and then submit the AC edits
2017-09-09 25229, 2017
CatQuest
proof is always useful for voters
2017-09-09 25230, 2017
culinko
so the people could vote on them
2017-09-09 25259, 2017
culinko
the thing is that i added the store links in the same edit chain
2017-09-09 25210, 2017
culinko
but the relationships are autoedits
2017-09-09 25230, 2017
CatQuest
well unfortiunatly i can't see those as they are auto's i think? so it's always usuefullto paste a hload of links in the edit note
2017-09-09 25234, 2017
culinko
too bad you can't see all the related edits in the same edit chain
2017-09-09 25250, 2017
CatQuest
anywa: for the future: what isaid earlier
2017-09-09 25254, 2017
CatQuest
:)
2017-09-09 25204, 2017
CatQuest
i'vehad to re-learn that lesson myself
2017-09-09 25208, 2017
culinko
so i thought it's redundant (e.g. the same edit note would also be displayed for the add relationship edits)
2017-09-09 25216, 2017
CatQuest
looking at 10 year old edits of my own going 2wtf was i doing?"
2017-09-09 25219, 2017
culinko
yeah i will try to add more stuff to the notes
2017-09-09 25222, 2017
CatQuest
+1!
2017-09-09 25238, 2017
culinko
also, what to do now about this release
2017-09-09 25244, 2017
CatQuest
with edit notes when i doubth: more is better
2017-09-09 25254, 2017
culinko
medium + recording has one AC, release + rg has the other AC
2017-09-09 25257, 2017
CatQuest
no idea. i'm going ot try focusing on instrments and not debussy
2017-09-09 25205, 2017
CatQuest
wish me luck!
2017-09-09 25215, 2017
culinko
good luck and have fun!
2017-09-09 25218, 2017
CatQuest
:D
2017-09-09 25254, 2017
culinko
also even though my edits didn't fail (luckily), is still have issues with editors making edits on entities that already have open edits. i acknowledge that you can miss it by accident, but if you are an experienced editor (which i assume autoeditors are) and you are making an autoedit, you should look at the open edits to check if there's anything conflicting and then discuss it before
2017-09-09 25254, 2017
culinko
submitting your autoedits
2017-09-09 25251, 2017
culinko
and as i said in the edit note, i don't have any issues with discussing the topic of digital media cover art vs store AC to figure out which one should be used
2017-09-09 25215, 2017
albertus1 has quit
2017-09-09 25258, 2017
spitzwegerich joined the channel
2017-09-09 25250, 2017
spitzwegerich
There are the countries "Germany" and "East Germany", but strangely, "West Germany" missing.
2017-09-09 25259, 2017
spitzwegerich
how to add it / request it?
2017-09-09 25219, 2017
spitzwegerich
Assigning releases "made in West Germany" just to "Germany" is not optimal IMO.
2017-09-09 25230, 2017
spitzwegerich
(I'm referring to the "manufacured in"-relationship)
2017-09-09 25241, 2017
agentsim joined the channel
2017-09-09 25251, 2017
albertus1 joined the channel
2017-09-09 25235, 2017
culinko has quit
2017-09-09 25207, 2017
reosarevok
spitzwegerich: that's because West Germany officially just switched into Germany for ISO - DE was the "Code used for West Germany before 1990 (previous ISO country name: Germany, Federal Republic of)"
2017-09-09 25224, 2017
reosarevok
So there's no different country in that sense in the official ISO list, West Germany is Germany
2017-09-09 25207, 2017
culinko joined the channel
2017-09-09 25208, 2017
culinko has quit
2017-09-09 25208, 2017
culinko joined the channel
2017-09-09 25237, 2017
chungy has quit
2017-09-09 25217, 2017
drsaunde joined the channel
2017-09-09 25205, 2017
d4rkie joined the channel
2017-09-09 25201, 2017
D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
2017-09-09 25242, 2017
naught101 has quit
2017-09-09 25241, 2017
naught101 joined the channel
2017-09-09 25213, 2017
CatQuest
spitzwegerich: i was thinking the exact same thing. i had several older cd releases was made in "west germany"
2017-09-09 25239, 2017
CatQuest
reosarevok: but that's a code weakeness
2017-09-09 25248, 2017
CatQuest
in reality, it's not true ™
2017-09-09 25259, 2017
CatQuest
(i mena if iwe had area-credits maybe)
2017-09-09 25245, 2017
SothoTalKer
was "West Germany" the official name? :)
2017-09-09 25259, 2017
culinko
quick question about digital media releases: does what is displayed on the cover art priority over what is displayed in the store or a streaming service? (iTunes, Google Play, Amazon, Spotify, YouTube)
2017-09-09 25214, 2017
culinko
i know in the case of physical releases it does, but not sure about digital media
2017-09-09 25232, 2017
culinko
cause "digital media covers" can sometimes be a little weird
