#musicbrainz

/

      • heyoni joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29408, 2017

      • heyoni has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29408, 2017

      • drsaunders joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29400, 2017

      • MajorLurker has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29450, 2017

      • jwf|matrix has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29450, 2017

      • jwf|matrix joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29410, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29440, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29440, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29449, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29425, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29457, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29429, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29441, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29420, 2017

      • mezod has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29417, 2017

      • matoro has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29456, 2017

      • MajorLurker joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29436, 2017

      • heyoni joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29423, 2017

      • heyoni has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29456, 2017

      • d4rkie joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29449, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29406, 2017

      • matoro joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29431, 2017

      • Gazooo joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29452, 2017

      • sparklyballs2 has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29437, 2017

      • d4rkie has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29439, 2017

      • MajorLurker has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29407, 2017

      • sparklyballs joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29444, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29439, 2017

      • randy_marsh joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29404, 2017

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29436, 2017

      • heyoni joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29450, 2017

      • DocPlatypus joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29408, 2017

      • heyoni has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29415, 2017

      • Vonter joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29443, 2017

      • chhavi_
        reosarevok: Tried adding a setlist for the concert.
      • 2017-10-21 29444, 2017

      • chhavi_
      • 2017-10-21 29450, 2017

      • chhavi_
        Did I do it right?
      • 2017-10-21 29424, 2017

      • MajorLurker joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29457, 2017

      • djr013 has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29445, 2017

      • djr013 joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29425, 2017

      • djr013
        chhavi_: it looks like you'll have to fix the links, even the one before your edit doesn't seem to work
      • 2017-10-21 29411, 2017

      • djr013
        it seems to assume that an mbid must be a link to a work, but the mbid seems intended to refer to a recording
      • 2017-10-21 29414, 2017

      • DocPlatypus has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29437, 2017

      • djr013
        you can create a recording link with [recording:##########|link title]
      • 2017-10-21 29459, 2017

      • djr013
        that said, linking to works makes more sense in a set list IMO
      • 2017-10-21 29428, 2017

      • djr013
        perhaps it's assuming they're works, due to context of being in setlist info
      • 2017-10-21 29414, 2017

      • djr013
      • 2017-10-21 29401, 2017

      • chhavi_
        Hey djr013 :) Thank you, let me try doing this
      • 2017-10-21 29435, 2017

      • djr013
      • 2017-10-21 29403, 2017

      • chhavi_
        [recording: 5fda04ca-e83f-454c-967b-95893a4f29bc |link Dreams Come True]
      • 2017-10-21 29412, 2017

      • chhavi_
        ^this is how you meant I should do it right?
      • 2017-10-21 29435, 2017

      • djr013
        I believe you can accomplish a link to a recording that way, yes. Though, it looks it's preferred (and possibly, required, I have no idea if the recording link will even work there) that you use a link to a work rather than a recording.
      • 2017-10-21 29414, 2017

      • djr013
        also, your link will wind up looking like "link Dreams Come True"
      • 2017-10-21 29435, 2017

      • djr013
        which you probably didn't intend :P
      • 2017-10-21 29430, 2017

      • chhavi_
        yes I don't intend that to happen :)
      • 2017-10-21 29403, 2017

      • chhavi_
        I am sorry, but I am lost. Wikipedia says I have to add "Dreams come true"
      • 2017-10-21 29404, 2017

      • chhavi_
      • 2017-10-21 29411, 2017

      • chhavi_
        This is what I am trying to add.
      • 2017-10-21 29433, 2017

      • djr013
        a work and a recording are two different specific things
      • 2017-10-21 29436, 2017

      • chhavi_
        But a work makes more sense in the setlist, like you said
      • 2017-10-21 29422, 2017

      • djr013
        but yes I'm not sure if there's a work for Dreams Come True or not, that recording isn't tagged with one
      • 2017-10-21 29442, 2017

      • djr013
        there are many works titled Dreams Come True, but I'm not sure any are relevant
      • 2017-10-21 29405, 2017

      • chhavi_
        okay, I am with you so far!
      • 2017-10-21 29412, 2017

      • djr013
        if it doesn't exist yet, you could either create the work, skip linking it and just say the name of the song, or use the recording link
      • 2017-10-21 29431, 2017

      • djr013
        using the recording would probably be more confusing than just leaving it with no link and just the title
      • 2017-10-21 29444, 2017

      • djr013
        at least then it's obvious there's not yet a link to a work
      • 2017-10-21 29457, 2017

      • chhavi_
        okay got it :) I will just leave it unlinked then.
      • 2017-10-21 29406, 2017

      • chhavi_
        yay. thank you djr013 :)
      • 2017-10-21 29433, 2017

      • djr013
        I don't think I've ever added a setlist either. :P I'm learning too
      • 2017-10-21 29446, 2017

      • chhavi_
        What are your views on it? How do you think we can make it easier to learn for people who try after us?
      • 2017-10-21 29437, 2017

      • randy_m4rsh joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29423, 2017

      • randy_marsh has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29430, 2017

      • djr013
        the linking syntax is pretty non-obvious, probably the easiest would be to have a form rather than free-entry
      • 2017-10-21 29418, 2017

      • djr013
        the documentation is fairly well linked at least
      • 2017-10-21 29441, 2017

      • djr013
        learning the linking syntax will make you into a very effective annotation writer though ;)
      • 2017-10-21 29432, 2017

      • chhavi_
        I found a ticket related to this
      • 2017-10-21 29433, 2017

      • chhavi_
      • 2017-10-21 29433, 2017

      • BrainzBot
        MBS-8120: Unify markup for annotations, setlists & notes
      • 2017-10-21 29424, 2017

      • chhavi_ trying to list down all problems with setlist. reosarevok Freso will hopefully add to it as well :)
      • 2017-10-21 29432, 2017

      • Darkloke joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29421, 2017

      • heyoni joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29411, 2017

      • heyoni has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29416, 2017

      • Leftmost
        Important question: if I'm adding a show that contained lip-synced performances set to recorded music by members of an established group (organization), do I add the group as an artist, or do I only add acts which performed music?
      • 2017-10-21 29435, 2017

      • MajorLurker
        Maybe we need a ¨lip synced¨ relationship :)
      • 2017-10-21 29407, 2017

      • Leftmost
        The punchline is I went to an event which was a combination rock show and drag show, and members of a Montana-based drag group (the Imperial Sovereign Court of the State of Montana) performed.
      • 2017-10-21 29443, 2017

      • MajorLurker
        Well I guess they meet the ¨performer¨ relationship then..
      • 2017-10-21 29425, 2017

      • simukis joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29436, 2017

      • Vonter has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29445, 2017

      • agentsim_ has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29459, 2017

      • agentsim joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29445, 2017

      • Vonter joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29432, 2017

      • randy_m4rsh has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29433, 2017

      • Vonter has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29417, 2017

      • heyoni joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29435, 2017

      • heyoni has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29454, 2017

      • hibiscuskazenek1 joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29405, 2017

      • MajorLurker has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29414, 2017

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29457, 2017

      • agentsim has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29440, 2017

      • MajorLurker joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29401, 2017

      • arbenina joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29445, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29459, 2017

      • reosarevok
        Leftmost: add them, if only because that name is too cool not to
      • 2017-10-21 29400, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29411, 2017

      • agentsim joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29457, 2017

      • agentsim has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29428, 2017

      • Toast joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29453, 2017

      • d4rkie joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29441, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29404, 2017

      • agentsim joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29402, 2017

      • agentsim has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29414, 2017

      • heyoni joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29427, 2017

      • heyoni has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29414, 2017

      • kharita joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29449, 2017

      • CatQuest agrees with reosarevok
      • 2017-10-21 29404, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29421, 2017

      • d4rkie has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29442, 2017

      • -- BotBot disconnected, possible missing messages --
      • 2017-10-21 29407, 2017

      • BrainzBot joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29413, 2017

      • agentsim has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29427, 2017

      • drsaunders has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29431, 2017

      • MajorLurker agrees with CatQuest
      • 2017-10-21 29432, 2017

      • arbenina has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29451, 2017

      • drsaunders joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29422, 2017

      • agentsim joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29441, 2017

      • agentsim has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29417, 2017

      • yvanzo doesn’t disagree with MajorLurker
      • 2017-10-21 29410, 2017

      • heyoni joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29421, 2017

      • heyoni has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29414, 2017

      • gioele joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29402, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29439, 2017

      • agentsim joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29404, 2017

      • agentsim has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29457, 2017

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29401, 2017

      • peaveyman has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29433, 2017

      • peaveyman joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29408, 2017

      • intcat has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29428, 2017

      • agentsim joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29432, 2017

      • intcat joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29457, 2017

      • agentsim has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29438, 2017

      • hibiscuskazenek1 has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29458, 2017

      • heyoni joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29455, 2017

      • agentsim joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29427, 2017

      • heyoni has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29418, 2017

      • agentsim has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29407, 2017

      • intcat has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29450, 2017

      • intcat joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29423, 2017

      • agentsim joined the channel
      • 2017-10-21 29452, 2017

      • agentsim has quit
      • 2017-10-21 29446, 2017

      • timbl joined the channel