#musicbrainz

/

      • CatQuest
        it sound coll etc
      • 2019-02-03 03459, 2019

      • CatQuest
        SothoTalKer_: this is true and a problm i have right now and also before :D
      • 2019-02-03 03437, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        5. can I type the name without learning how to enter diacritics and fancy characters?
      • 2019-02-03 03448, 2019

      • CatQuest
        piano is a keyboard instrument, a chordophone, a string instrument where the string vibrating creates the sound and the bit making the strings vibrate is percussion 😅
      • 2019-02-03 03411, 2019

      • SothoTalKer_
        german wikipedia lists both types
      • 2019-02-03 03423, 2019

      • SothoTalKer_
        Chordophon and "Tasteninstrument"
      • 2019-02-03 03437, 2019

      • CatQuest
        keybaord isn't a type (thank god)
      • 2019-02-03 03437, 2019

      • CatQuest
        and the other 3 all have "strings2 as a refrecne so strings it is
      • 2019-02-03 03439, 2019

      • CatQuest
        (for now)
      • 2019-02-03 03401, 2019

      • CatQuest
        might.. be able to make "keyboard" is a part of piano"
      • 2019-02-03 03412, 2019

      • CatQuest
        which wouldn't be wrong
      • 2019-02-03 03427, 2019

      • SothoTalKer_
        The piano is an acoustic, stringed musical instrument
      • 2019-02-03 03433, 2019

      • CatQuest
        but it's feelsbadman.jpg
      • 2019-02-03 03445, 2019

      • CatQuest
        SothoTalKer_: 🙋
      • 2019-02-03 03402, 2019

      • SothoTalKer_
        Hornbostel-Sachs classification: 314.122-4-8
      • 2019-02-03 03402, 2019

      • SothoTalKer_
        (Simple chordophone with keyboard sounded by hammers)
      • 2019-02-03 03407, 2019

      • CatQuest
        exactly
      • 2019-02-03 03425, 2019

      • CatQuest
        (which was my argument and exact quote, but hell what do i know about instruments right? :D)
      • 2019-02-03 03437, 2019

      • SothoTalKer_
        you are the instrument master!
      • 2019-02-03 03440, 2019

      • CatQuest
        hahaha
      • 2019-02-03 03404, 2019

      • Jinx has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03441, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        which is to say, you're like the beast master but you can talk to marimbas
      • 2019-02-03 03457, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        the bad guys don't stand a chance.
      • 2019-02-03 03435, 2019

      • CatQuest
        hahahahahaha
      • 2019-02-03 03439, 2019

      • CatQuest
        :D
      • 2019-02-03 03430, 2019

      • timbl has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03443, 2019

      • SothoTalKer_
        :-)
      • 2019-02-03 03443, 2019

      • Leo_Verto has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03424, 2019

      • albertus1 joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03445, 2019

      • Leo_Verto joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03456, 2019

      • icantodd has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03441, 2019

      • Jybz joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03436, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03451, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03401, 2019

      • Gazooo has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03447, 2019

      • Slurpee has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03448, 2019

      • Gazooo joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03429, 2019

      • Slurpee joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03412, 2019

      • slurpee- joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03449, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03414, 2019

      • Slurpee has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03449, 2019

      • slurpee- has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03453, 2019

      • simukis_ has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03401, 2019

      • c1e0 has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03410, 2019

      • Vexatos has left the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03400, 2019

      • Jybz has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03423, 2019

      • Jybz joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03425, 2019

      • Jybz has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03446, 2019

      • Jybz joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03417, 2019

      • amCap1712 has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03447, 2019

      • TrisquelWhare
        michelv: Sorry, I'm unsure what you mean by "𝑰 𝒔𝒆𝒆 𝒚𝒐𝒖 𝒉𝒂𝒗𝒆 𝒂𝒅𝒅𝒆𝒅 𝒕𝒂𝒈𝒔 𝒕𝒐 𝒚𝒐𝒖𝒓 𝒓𝒆𝒍𝒆𝒂𝒔𝒆𝒔" and about whether or not that is intentional. Is there some problem with doing this? I was following the example of @aerozol, who has an extensive / impressive collection of personal tags.
      • 2019-02-03 03409, 2019

      • albertus1 has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03431, 2019

      • Jybz has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03423, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        there are no bad tags
      • 2019-02-03 03422, 2019

      • CatQuest tries to not disagree
      • 2019-02-03 03410, 2019

      • CatQuest
        well I guess tags are for everything :)
      • 2019-02-03 03435, 2019

      • CatQuest
        itcould be a collection could also serve your purpose though :)
      • 2019-02-03 03440, 2019

      • CatQuest
        TrisquelWhare^
      • 2019-02-03 03442, 2019

      • jwf
        Could someone add a tie-breaker vote to these two edits?
      • 2019-02-03 03444, 2019

      • jwf
      • 2019-02-03 03446, 2019

      • jwf
      • 2019-02-03 03420, 2019

      • TrisquelWhare
        CatQuest: yes, I've been making collections as well, and at present there does seem to be some overlap. Once I am more familiar with MB I'll no doubt decide on one or the other as working best for me.
      • 2019-02-03 03403, 2019

      • Krystof joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03446, 2019

      • TrisquelWhare has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03413, 2019

      • albertus1 joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03423, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        jwf, since you're asking for help/opinions on interpreting the guidelines, maybe a forum thread? I'd be curious to hear how other people interpret it.
      • 2019-02-03 03415, 2019

      • CatQuest
        what *I* am having troubles with is that the cover doesn't seem to say anything. so i don't know what to say :D
      • 2019-02-03 03450, 2019

      • CatQuest
        anyway the disswant of "-" in titles is probably a left over from when *any* " - " in titles was considered nope (as usually it was used for both extra title info and subtitles )
      • 2019-02-03 03413, 2019

      • CatQuest
        but that's something: how do we know that "volume alpha" is even a "volume2 ? and not just part o the name?
      • 2019-02-03 03422, 2019

      • CatQuest
        is thre a "volume beta"?
      • 2019-02-03 03435, 2019

      • CatQuest
        but that's something: how do we know that "volume alpha" is even a "volume" ? and not just part o the name?
      • 2019-02-03 03421, 2019

      • CatQuest
        or like, "alpha" in this case could simply mean "from the alpha stage of the game" (as an example)
      • 2019-02-03 03434, 2019

      • CatQuest
        rarg lack of title on the cover :D
      • 2019-02-03 03457, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        CatQuest, there is a volume beta
      • 2019-02-03 03449, 2019

      • CatQuest
        :O
      • 2019-02-03 03400, 2019

      • CatQuest
        is ther eany text on its cover?
      • 2019-02-03 03458, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        The only version with text that I saw was the sticker on discogs. https://www.discogs.com/release/8089200
      • 2019-02-03 03433, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        So partly I wonder, is the guideline meant to
      • 2019-02-03 03445, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        1) improve human readability?
      • 2019-02-03 03442, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        2) standardize on one separator for consistency?
      • 2019-02-03 03404, 2019

      • CatQuest
        2 was deff true before. i think
      • 2019-02-03 03414, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        agreed
      • 2019-02-03 03434, 2019

      • CatQuest
        i honestly don't find " - " less legible than ", "
      • 2019-02-03 03456, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        or 3) provide some form of separation when the cover uses formatting to achieve it
      • 2019-02-03 03403, 2019

      • CatQuest
        ding!
      • 2019-02-03 03410, 2019

      • CatQuest
        2 and 3 together i think
      • 2019-02-03 03404, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        the 2 people have been steadily losing to the "as on cover" people
      • 2019-02-03 03416, 2019

      • CatQuest
        (and on 3 we default to ", " mostly for reasons of "2)" (consistency) and also history)
      • 2019-02-03 03400, 2019

      • CatQuest
        i' ma "as on cover person" and "format introduced ETI" is a huge pita
      • 2019-02-03 03417, 2019

      • CatQuest
        becasue i can't make something a differnt font or next line :D
      • 2019-02-03 03423, 2019

      • CatQuest
        so : or , will have to do
      • 2019-02-03 03425, 2019

      • xplt has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03450, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        yeah, in a perfect world title "parts" would have separate fields
      • 2019-02-03 03418, 2019

      • CatQuest
        eh. i don't liek that either.
      • 2019-02-03 03439, 2019

      • CatQuest
        like*
      • 2019-02-03 03450, 2019

      • CatQuest
        eh it's too late
      • 2019-02-03 03452, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        no? it'd let you format them however you like
      • 2019-02-03 03400, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        yeah, probably true
      • 2019-02-03 03411, 2019

      • CatQuest
        i don't know why, i just don't like it :D
      • 2019-02-03 03435, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        a long time ago brian wrote a form where you'd put in the different "parts" of a classical title and a script would output the CSG™ title.
      • 2019-02-03 03409, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        ... and I was like "what? why combine them? you're going the wrong way!"
      • 2019-02-03 03431, 2019

      • CatQuest
        well classical, thats a different thing altogether :)
      • 2019-02-03 03453, 2019

      • Slurpee joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03413, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        sure, but it was a glimpse of how things could have been
      • 2019-02-03 03452, 2019

      • CallerNo6
        same for sort names
      • 2019-02-03 03436, 2019

      • naught101 joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03448, 2019

      • JoeLlama joined the channel
      • 2019-02-03 03435, 2019

      • legoktm is now known as legoktm[NE]
      • 2019-02-03 03424, 2019

      • JoeLlama has quit
      • 2019-02-03 03453, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit