Hi, I'm looking for some style clarification. I'd like to enter the following release: https://theshortsleeves.bandcamp.com/album/black-… - From the style guide I'm not entirely sure if I should remove the "live" parts from the release and/or track titles (I'd add them as recording comments and with the appropriate relationships, of course)
2019-07-02 18321, 2019
Protab joined the channel
2019-07-02 18302, 2019
Rotab has quit
2019-07-02 18338, 2019
plutes has quit
2019-07-02 18325, 2019
Jinx has quit
2019-07-02 18343, 2019
Jinx joined the channel
2019-07-02 18355, 2019
zas
elomatreb[m]: yes, they should be removed because it's not part of the title, and doesn't help to differentiate tracks.
2019-07-02 18351, 2019
Yaniel
one could argue that it is part of the release title though
2019-07-02 18342, 2019
Nyanko-sensei joined the channel
2019-07-02 18358, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
2019-07-02 18304, 2019
Nyanko-sensei has quit
2019-07-02 18358, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
2019-07-02 18319, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
2019-07-02 18337, 2019
albertus11 has quit
2019-07-02 18347, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
2019-07-02 18350, 2019
albertus1 joined the channel
2019-07-02 18342, 2019
Vonter has quit
2019-07-02 18314, 2019
reosarevok
Yeah, I could see it left at the release but probably not every track
censor-style: I’d do either the uncensored version all the way or alternatively to censored version as track name and change the recording name to uncensored.
2019-07-02 18301, 2019
rdswift joined the channel
2019-07-02 18308, 2019
Freso
(I generally lean towards following the cover, but for me, this includes the booklet, and if the booklet has a more precise track naming than the back cover, then I give preference to that.)
2019-07-02 18312, 2019
BCMM has quit
2019-07-02 18325, 2019
censor-style
It is obvious to me that artist intent was overridden by commercial interests for the back cover.
2019-07-02 18351, 2019
chaban has quit
2019-07-02 18332, 2019
chaban joined the channel
2019-07-02 18355, 2019
reosarevok
Uncensored sounds better to me
2019-07-02 18303, 2019
reosarevok
If at all printed (like here)
2019-07-02 18307, 2019
samj1912 joined the channel
2019-07-02 18326, 2019
Freso
I mean, that was what I argued for first/primarily. The other option was only if you really disagree with that. :)
2019-07-02 18345, 2019
reosarevok
I know, just adding my voice to the choir
2019-07-02 18331, 2019
BCMM joined the channel
2019-07-02 18303, 2019
censor-style
how do new style guidelines go on the wiki? is there some kind of discussion / approval process?
