#musicbrainz

/

      • kepstin-work
        and I only know of the W. because that's needed to distinguish him from his father
      • 2013-07-29 21024, 2013

      • hawke_1
        kepstin-work: his father is H.W. (Herbert Walker)
      • 2013-07-29 21045, 2013

      • hawke_1
        Anyway, I guess the point I was getting at (with Tchaikovsky): Is the reason that Estonian excludes the middle name, because Estonians only have first/last? or just because no one bothered to add the middle name?
      • 2013-07-29 21052, 2013

      • reosarevok
        hawke_1: from my experience, Americans using Name1 Initial Name2 is reasonably common (not a majority thing maybe but still common) while elsewhere it's nonexistant, except in Russia where it's the same in a different way
      • 2013-07-29 21013, 2013

      • oloP
        also, second names are never in wikipedia introduction, and middle names are :)
      • 2013-07-29 21025, 2013

      • reosarevok
        mknjc_: you don't need to *exactly* recreate them by hand, in that just going there and selecting "add new recordings" for each one will do that itself
      • 2013-07-29 21056, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        simukis_: I tend to tag touhou stuff, so http://musicbrainz.org/tag/touhou has a bunch of things
      • 2013-07-29 21010, 2013

      • reosarevok
        hawke_1: from what I've seen, ethnic Russian names in Estonian never use patronymics
      • 2013-07-29 21021, 2013

      • reosarevok
        (and there are lots of ethnic Russians living around)
      • 2013-07-29 21027, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        simukis_: oh, 発熱巫女~ず (hatsunetsumiko's) is pretty good too :)
      • 2013-07-29 21049, 2013

      • hawke_1
        reosarevok: That doesn’t mean it’s not part of their name, though…
      • 2013-07-29 21017, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Well, I don't know how they're *registered*, I haven't seen their passports
      • 2013-07-29 21032, 2013

      • hawke_1
        I mean, my full name is “Alex Leonard Mauer”, even though the middle name only appears on my birth certificate, and the middle initial only on credit cards and such.
      • 2013-07-29 21051, 2013

      • hawke_1
        I don’t *use* that name, but it’s still there.
      • 2013-07-29 21011, 2013

      • hawke_1
        And it would still be there even if I moved to spain or estonia or iceland. :-)
      • 2013-07-29 21034, 2013

      • reosarevok
      • 2013-07-29 21042, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        hawke_1: hmm, some countries have (or at least used to have) interesting laws regarding foreign names :)
      • 2013-07-29 21006, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Also notice all of those aliases which are marked as somthing aren't marked as "legal name" :p
      • 2013-07-29 21009, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        eg. until recently, in order to become a japanese citizen, you'd have to choose a native japanese name...
      • 2013-07-29 21018, 2013

      • simukis_
        kepstin-work: what's with zu at the end?
      • 2013-07-29 21028, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        simukis_: they're being silly.
      • 2013-07-29 21037, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        that's the 's
      • 2013-07-29 21043, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        in hatsunetsumiko's
      • 2013-07-29 21048, 2013

      • hawke_1
        reosarevok: But that’s because it only has fields for …what, given name, and surname? — they don’t have a 'full name' field.
      • 2013-07-29 21023, 2013

      • hawke_1
        If someone asked me to fill something out and it only listed first/last name (or given/family name) I would only do the first and the last…not because it’s specifically excluded.
      • 2013-07-29 21040, 2013

      • reosarevok
        huh, an American passport sample doesn't seem to have a full name field either
      • 2013-07-29 21052, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        U.S. and Canada passport applications explicitly request that you fill out first, middle, and surnames iirc.
      • 2013-07-29 21057, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Only "Given names" and "surname"
      • 2013-07-29 21004, 2013

      • hawke_1
        right
      • 2013-07-29 21053, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        hmm. the canadian application apparently is requesting "Surname (last name)", "Given name(s)", "Surname (last name) at birth", "Former surname (former last name)", and "Mother's maiden name"
      • 2013-07-29 21033, 2013

      • reosarevok
        A Russian one seems to use the same as the American one too, Surname / Given names (which I expect is anyway an international convention) in both Cyrillic in Latin with "Given names" seemingly always including the patronymic in Cyrillic but only sometimes (maybe for old ones?) in Latin
      • 2013-07-29 21042, 2013

      • hawke joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21037, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Which makes sense, since I think Tchaikovsky and, to some level, Lenin are the only two Russians for which I've often seen the patronymic being used when using their names in Latin script
      • 2013-07-29 21020, 2013

      • reosarevok
        I've pretty much never seen it used for, say, Stravinsky or Prokofiev in Latin
      • 2013-07-29 21026, 2013

      • hawke_1
        Maybe Latin just really lives “Illyich”?
      • 2013-07-29 21030, 2013

      • hawke_1
        *loves
      • 2013-07-29 21031, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Maybe!
      • 2013-07-29 21049, 2013

      • kepstin-work found the signup form on https://www.minc.gr.jp/ to be quite amusing, in how it asks for your family/given name 3 times, once each in kanji, kana, and latin transliteration.
      • 2013-07-29 21056, 2013

      • reosarevok
        mknjc_: when/if you enter said edits, feel free to paste a link here for us to approve them since the issue is obviously wrong now :)
      • 2013-07-29 21033, 2013

      • warp
        kepstin-work: wow, fun. are any of them optional?
      • 2013-07-29 21049, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        warp: you only have to fill in one of either the kana or latin, iirc.
      • 2013-07-29 21003, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        and it also asks which prefecture in japan you live in, and doesn't give any options appropriate to foreigners, yes :)
      • 2013-07-29 21027, 2013

      • warp
        :)
      • 2013-07-29 21041, 2013

      • hawke_1
        …is it worth keeping birth/death dates in search hints?
      • 2013-07-29 21011, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        hawke_1: they're not birth/death dates, they're start/end dates :)
      • 2013-07-29 21054, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        you should go and find out when that alias was first used to refer to the person, and set that as the start date :)
      • 2013-07-29 21013, 2013

      • hawke_1
        Well, in this case it’s a birth/death date. :-p
      • 2013-07-29 21035, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        well, did we stop using that name after the person died? no? then remove the end date ;)
      • 2013-07-29 21041, 2013

      • hawke_1
        Anyway, “Peter Iljitsch Tschaikowsky (1840 - 1893)” doesn’t seem worth keeping…
      • 2013-07-29 21048, 2013

      • kepstin-work is sort of kidding. but yeah.
      • 2013-07-29 21059, 2013

      • hawke_1
        but should I add '1840' and '1893' as search hints…
      • 2013-07-29 21034, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        pretty much the only reason to use the start/end dates is if someone changed their name at some point
      • 2013-07-29 21041, 2013

      • hawke_1
        understood.
      • 2013-07-29 21046, 2013

      • hawke_1
        I’m talking about in the name itself.
      • 2013-07-29 21008, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        i wouldn't add the dates as names
      • 2013-07-29 21025, 2013

      • hawke_1
        Presumably some CD case listed the dates and so someone added it like that, and then it got merged/edited.
      • 2013-07-29 21041, 2013

      • hawke_1
        but I’m not sure whether that’s not a useful search hint…
      • 2013-07-29 21052, 2013

      • reosarevok
        It's not
      • 2013-07-29 21055, 2013

      • hawke_1
        OK.
      • 2013-07-29 21007, 2013

      • reosarevok
        But you might argue we should be showing that info in inline search, and I wouldn't disagree with you
      • 2013-07-29 21017, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Feel free to ticket if there's none (nikki?)
      • 2013-07-29 21043, 2013

      • hawke_1
        Perhaps — I would be more inclined to suggest that it just be included in the searched fields
      • 2013-07-29 21045, 2013

      • hawke_1
        if it’s not already
      • 2013-07-29 21049, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Well, it feels more like disambiguation than search to me
      • 2013-07-29 21005, 2013

      • santiissopasse joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21036, 2013

      • jcazevedo joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21034, 2013

      • mknjc_
      • 2013-07-29 21035, 2013

      • mknjc_
      • 2013-07-29 21013, 2013

      • reosarevok
        wow, fucking mess
      • 2013-07-29 21014, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Ok
      • 2013-07-29 21035, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Let's check :)
      • 2013-07-29 21051, 2013

      • reosarevok
        mknjc_: approved, http://musicbrainz.org/recording/b0778cbe-9765-4a… looks better now
      • 2013-07-29 21004, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Thankfully it didn't have any fingerprints attached
      • 2013-07-29 21024, 2013

      • mknjc_
        yes 48 records on 12 releases
      • 2013-07-29 21054, 2013

      • mknjc_
        reosarevok: thank you for approving :-)
      • 2013-07-29 21013, 2013

      • adhawkins-away joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21019, 2013

      • Mistah_Darcy joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21009, 2013

      • Schisma___ joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21023, 2013

      • Muz joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21024, 2013

      • mchou_ joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21050, 2013

      • royale1223 joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21055, 2013

      • Krystof joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21048, 2013

      • portik joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21019, 2013

      • oloP
        hawke_1 : maybe tchaikovsky used to sign with all his names, and not prokoviev nor stravinsky
      • 2013-07-29 21012, 2013

      • hawke_1
        oloP: Perhaps, but I don’t think signature is the same as name…
      • 2013-07-29 21024, 2013

      • hawke_1
      • 2013-07-29 21048, 2013

      • oloP
        tchaikovsky didn't either
      • 2013-07-29 21003, 2013

      • oloP
      • 2013-07-29 21012, 2013

      • oloP
        so it's not the reason
      • 2013-07-29 21042, 2013

      • hawke_1
        Yep¸I saw that now too
      • 2013-07-29 21018, 2013

      • portik has left the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21048, 2013

      • intgr
        Can I have an approve please? Trying to enter a new release version and it turns out some track lengths and AcoustIDs are different: https://musicbrainz.org/edit/23124306
      • 2013-07-29 21000, 2013

      • intgr
        The recording's won't be created until approved.
      • 2013-07-29 21032, 2013

      • hawke_1
        approved
      • 2013-07-29 21045, 2013

      • intgr
        Thanks ﺕ
      • 2013-07-29 21051, 2013

      • hawke_1
        Anyone know why the “Sweden Swedish” entry on http://beta.musicbrainz.org/artist/9ddd7abc-9e1b-… is specific to Sweden?
      • 2013-07-29 21030, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Nope
      • 2013-07-29 21034, 2013

      • reosarevok
        I wondered the same
      • 2013-07-29 21050, 2013

      • hawke_1
        Should I just change it to 'swedish'?
      • 2013-07-29 21001, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Maybe it was added by a Swede who wasn't fully sure the Finland Swedes use the same, but I'm more partial to the thought it's just silly :p
      • 2013-07-29 21020, 2013

      • hawke_1 edits it.
      • 2013-07-29 21029, 2013

      • hawke_1
        If Finland Swedish has it different, they can add it. :-p
      • 2013-07-29 21054, 2013

      • hawke_1
        reosarevok: are there area aliases?
      • 2013-07-29 21059, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Yes
      • 2013-07-29 21013, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        are they editable by normal users?
      • 2013-07-29 21018, 2013

      • reosarevok
        No
      • 2013-07-29 21039, 2013

      • reosarevok
        IIRC they're also auto-imported from wikipedia/wikidata
      • 2013-07-29 21045, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        I presume they're imported from wikida... yeah.
      • 2013-07-29 21047, 2013

      • reosarevok
        But they were only imported for some stuff
      • 2013-07-29 21049, 2013

      • hawke_1
        auto-updated too?
      • 2013-07-29 21002, 2013

      • reosarevok
        ask nikki when she's around
      • 2013-07-29 21008, 2013

      • hawke_1
        “Sankt-Peterburg” needs “Saint Petersburg” and “St. Petersburg”
      • 2013-07-29 21014, 2013

      • reosarevok
      • 2013-07-29 21020, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Oh, I thought I had added that one
      • 2013-07-29 21036, 2013

      • reosarevok does it
      • 2013-07-29 21010, 2013

      • hawke_1
        And the search engine needs less suck — the hyphen should be a word break
      • 2013-07-29 21015, 2013

      • jcazevedo joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21019, 2013

      • hawke_1
        (or something)
      • 2013-07-29 21032, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Done
      • 2013-07-29 21037, 2013

      • reosarevok
        the aliases :p
      • 2013-07-29 21040, 2013

      • hawke_1
        thx
      • 2013-07-29 21043, 2013

      • kepstin-work
        really, the hyphen should be both a word break and no-a-word-break when searching :/
      • 2013-07-29 21002, 2013

      • hawke_1
        …Maybe it’s just the derpy “first word is super hyper incredi-important, ignore the second word”
      • 2013-07-29 21011, 2013

      • reosarevok
        dunno, I never remember how the English one is written anyway so I tend to use the Estonian
      • 2013-07-29 21015, 2013

      • reosarevok
        (hence adding that alias too)
      • 2013-07-29 21017, 2013

      • hawke_1
        (since 'petersburg' gives reasonable results, but 'st. petersburg' and 'saint petersburg' give horrible results
      • 2013-07-29 21035, 2013

      • hawke_1
        What are the attributes I need to add to get MB to import a place?
      • 2013-07-29 21010, 2013

      • reosarevok
        p131 and p31
      • 2013-07-29 21008, 2013

      • drsaunde joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21016, 2013

      • hawke_1
        thanks
      • 2013-07-29 21013, 2013

      • murk_ joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21025, 2013

      • hawke_1
        We still don’t have historical areas, right?
      • 2013-07-29 21044, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Not really, except for the countries we had before
      • 2013-07-29 21022, 2013

      • santiissopasse_ joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21035, 2013

      • yindesu joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21027, 2013

      • hawke_1
      • 2013-07-29 21047, 2013

      • hawke_1
        It seems insane to me to put recording date/location in the disambig of *every* recording now…
      • 2013-07-29 21053, 2013

      • hawke_1
        …which is what that thread implies
      • 2013-07-29 21002, 2013

      • nikki
        that would seem rather useless
      • 2013-07-29 21035, 2013

      • nikki
        at least for the sort of stuff I edit, rerecorded non-live versions are usually pretty clearly marked as being rerecordings :P
      • 2013-07-29 21051, 2013

      • nikki
        (because look! new recording! buy itttt!)
      • 2013-07-29 21057, 2013

      • hawke_1
        hehe
      • 2013-07-29 21021, 2013

      • reosarevok
      • 2013-07-29 21040, 2013

      • nikki
        it sounds strange to me to call a poet a lyricist
      • 2013-07-29 21009, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Same - I'm mostly wondering if there are people who agree with him though
      • 2013-07-29 21013, 2013

      • hawke_1
        yep, same here
      • 2013-07-29 21016, 2013

      • reosarevok shrugs - I can't see a big problem with that info there at least until we have a better way to store it
      • 2013-07-29 21021, 2013

      • reosarevok
        (re: the forum post)
      • 2013-07-29 21033, 2013

      • CatQuest joined the channel
      • 2013-07-29 21038, 2013

      • hawke_1
        I think it’s just overzealous application of “prefer wrote→lyrics”