#musicbrainz

/

      • deadchip
        we are aware of the shortcomings
      • 2006-08-04 21640, 2006

      • deadchip
        but it takes time to come up with a clean solution
      • 2006-08-04 21650, 2006

      • deadchip
        i haven't done any kind of odd hackcs yet in the whole development process
      • 2006-08-04 21651, 2006

      • deadchip
        and i won't
      • 2006-08-04 21605, 2006

      • deadchip
        if it takes 6 months to come up with a proper solution for something, then it will take that long
      • 2006-08-04 21613, 2006

      • deadchip
        we're not planning on releasing BMP 2 anywhere soon
      • 2006-08-04 21617, 2006

      • deadchip
        btw it's called BMPx because it's
      • 2006-08-04 21618, 2006

      • deadchip
        erm
      • 2006-08-04 21620, 2006

      • insta
        deadchip: you need to chill out a bit, I'm not bashing anything, and I'm still running bmpx ... it's lasted past the 30-second window of having to wow me, and it's gonna stick around
      • 2006-08-04 21622, 2006

      • deadchip
        like the about page says
      • 2006-08-04 21643, 2006

      • deadchip
        BMPx is the current upstream product from our experimental codebase, that will eventually produce BMP 2.0 (see chapter below). The `bmpx' codebase is also currently being ported to C++, and the final BMP 2.0 will ship as a C++ application using GTKmm.
      • 2006-08-04 21651, 2006

      • deadchip
        see we had to develop this openly
      • 2006-08-04 21600, 2006

      • deadchip
        developing it behind closed doors is nonsense
      • 2006-08-04 21609, 2006

      • deadchip
        but the current code does not qualify by any standards and means as a "pre-BMP 2"
      • 2006-08-04 21627, 2006

      • deadchip
        so we call it "BMPx" for now, as the "current upstream product from.." well, what it says above
      • 2006-08-04 21641, 2006

      • deadchip
        some features work very well, and are ok, some things are less good
      • 2006-08-04 21653, 2006

      • deadchip
        insta: heh ok
      • 2006-08-04 21607, 2006

      • deadchip
        well you can try the library and the musicbrainz retagging it's very efficient
      • 2006-08-04 21615, 2006

      • insta
        should i have done the "retag files and import" option instead of just import?
      • 2006-08-04 21621, 2006

      • insta
        i kinda jumped the gun
      • 2006-08-04 21633, 2006

      • deadchip
        well there are 2 ways of importing music
      • 2006-08-04 21636, 2006

      • deadchip
        one is just to import it
      • 2006-08-04 21643, 2006

      • deadchip
        that imports files as they are first of all
      • 2006-08-04 21648, 2006

      • deadchip
        then you can edit the metadata later on
      • 2006-08-04 21658, 2006

      • deadchip
        or, if you want to pick a few particular files of which you know they constitute a release
      • 2006-08-04 21602, 2006

      • deadchip
        then you use what you just chose
      • 2006-08-04 21617, 2006

      • deadchip
        and select them, and then choose the musicbrainz release, and then it retags them first and then imports them
      • 2006-08-04 21625, 2006

      • deadchip
        but that's quite tedious if you have really a lot of albums
      • 2006-08-04 21641, 2006

      • insta
        deadchip: I'm really kinda disappointed with the import speed :(
      • 2006-08-04 21651, 2006

      • insta
        It doesn't do 110GB over 100mbit network fast enough ;)
      • 2006-08-04 21614, 2006

      • deadchip
        heh
      • 2006-08-04 21639, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: there is a build system problem in 0.5
      • 2006-08-04 21648, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: it didn't build the tta plugin but it still tries to install it
      • 2006-08-04 21651, 2006

      • luks
        i know
      • 2006-08-04 21656, 2006

      • deadchip
        the link in examples/plugins/ is dangling
      • 2006-08-04 21657, 2006

      • deadchip
        ok
      • 2006-08-04 21601, 2006

      • luks
        i'm about to release 0.5.1 this week
      • 2006-08-04 21614, 2006

      • deadchip
        ok just in case you didn't... know..
      • 2006-08-04 21642, 2006

      • tro has quit
      • 2006-08-04 21642, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: under what circumstances would PUID lookup work for one person with the exact same file (note, not just the same track but exactly the same file) and for another person not?
      • 2006-08-04 21610, 2006

      • deadchip
        given that support for this filetype has been built with the library (libtunepimp) on both systems
      • 2006-08-04 21641, 2006

      • luks
        it doesn't generate a PUID or it MB gives you different matches?
      • 2006-08-04 21602, 2006

      • deadchip
        for me, it returns No PUID
      • 2006-08-04 21609, 2006

      • deadchip
        for the other guy, it gives a result for the same track
      • 2006-08-04 21624, 2006

      • toxickore has quit
      • 2006-08-04 21622, 2006

      • deadchip
        me:
      • 2006-08-04 21624, 2006

      • deadchip
        No PUID available for this track.
      • 2006-08-04 21626, 2006

      • deadchip
        David:
      • 2006-08-04 21637, 2006

      • deadchip
        Artist: 'The Prodigy feat. Max Romeo'
      • 2006-08-04 21641, 2006

      • deadchip
        Album: 'Outta Space'
      • 2006-08-04 21646, 2006

      • deadchip
        Track: 'Outta Space (Cut 'n Run Booty Space Mix)'
      • 2006-08-04 21652, 2006

      • deadchip
        TrackNum: '0'
      • 2006-08-04 21656, 2006

      • deadchip
        Duration: '440710'
      • 2006-08-04 21601, 2006

      • deadchip
        PUID: 4a46a284-d0e4-ec81-1502-dbc7c6e7c9a8
      • 2006-08-04 21606, 2006

      • luks
        hm, that's weird
      • 2006-08-04 21651, 2006

      • luks
        and does it return you puid for some other track?
      • 2006-08-04 21601, 2006

      • deadchip
        nope
      • 2006-08-04 21602, 2006

      • deadchip
        for none so far
      • 2006-08-04 21606, 2006

      • deadchip
        i tried with wav and mp3 files
      • 2006-08-04 21614, 2006

      • deadchip
        i tried rather common stuff like
      • 2006-08-04 21621, 2006

      • deadchip
        from the discovery album by daft punk
      • 2006-08-04 21630, 2006

      • luks
        that it could be a problem of the libtp install
      • 2006-08-04 21631, 2006

      • deadchip
        i didn't even think this track above there ^^^
      • 2006-08-04 21635, 2006

      • deadchip
        would be registered at all
      • 2006-08-04 21641, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: what should i check for?
      • 2006-08-04 21609, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: well it does do somethin
      • 2006-08-04 21611, 2006

      • deadchip
        +g
      • 2006-08-04 21611, 2006

      • luks
        maybe stupid question, but is the mp3 plugin compiled correctly?
      • 2006-08-04 21619, 2006

      • deadchip
        it's not like it returns immediatly and says "No PUID"
      • 2006-08-04 21624, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: humm
      • 2006-08-04 21625, 2006

      • deadchip
        let me check
      • 2006-08-04 21626, 2006

      • luks
        the puid app should give you a list of supported formats
      • 2006-08-04 21636, 2006

      • deadchip
        Supported file extensions: .aac .asf .flac .m4a .m4b .m4p .mp3 .mp4 .mpc .ogg .spx .wav .wma .wv
      • 2006-08-04 21641, 2006

      • luks
        hmm
      • 2006-08-04 21629, 2006

      • luks
        i can only think of some network problem then
      • 2006-08-04 21652, 2006

      • deadchip
        mp3.tpp is linked against musicbrainz, libofa and libmad
      • 2006-08-04 21657, 2006

      • deadchip
        humm
      • 2006-08-04 21658, 2006

      • deadchip
        network
      • 2006-08-04 21602, 2006

      • deadchip starts ethereal
      • 2006-08-04 21605, 2006

      • deadchip
        well
      • 2006-08-04 21607, 2006

      • deadchip
        well ok
      • 2006-08-04 21625, 2006

      • insta
        deadchip: it's still importing ...
      • 2006-08-04 21615, 2006

      • deadchip
        insta: well try importing that much with rhythmbox then you can leave for a workday
      • 2006-08-04 21621, 2006

      • deadchip
        i once made a benchmark of bmpx vs. RB
      • 2006-08-04 21633, 2006

      • deadchip
        it took BMPx for ~2000 files 1:35 minutes and for RB 18 minutes 30
      • 2006-08-04 21601, 2006

      • insta
        deadchip: actually rhythmbox takes about an hour on this library
      • 2006-08-04 21602, 2006

      • Pienne joined the channel
      • 2006-08-04 21643, 2006

      • deadchip
      • 2006-08-04 21645, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: ?
      • 2006-08-04 21647, 2006

      • insta
        Just sayin
      • 2006-08-04 21602, 2006

      • luks
        yep, that's right
      • 2006-08-04 21605, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: ok
      • 2006-08-04 21609, 2006

      • luks
        that should return some xml
      • 2006-08-04 21610, 2006

      • deadchip
        well it returns then
      • 2006-08-04 21614, 2006

      • ruaok has left the channel
      • 2006-08-04 21636, 2006

      • ruaok joined the channel
      • 2006-08-04 21640, 2006

      • ruaok
        carp.
      • 2006-08-04 21615, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: i think it's really a network problem
      • 2006-08-04 21630, 2006

      • deadchip
        if there ever comes in a response it's fragemented and it is not an XML document
      • 2006-08-04 21638, 2006

      • deadchip
        i'm watching what happens trough ethereal
      • 2006-08-04 21646, 2006

      • luks
        hmm, wait
      • 2006-08-04 21650, 2006

      • luks
      • 2006-08-04 21655, 2006

      • luks
      • 2006-08-04 21607, 2006

      • Shepard
        klept-o-rama, ruaok
      • 2006-08-04 21612, 2006

      • deadchip
        luks: yeah typo sorry
      • 2006-08-04 21617, 2006

      • deadchip
        it's ofa allright
      • 2006-08-04 21625, 2006

      • luks
        ugh, you types the URL manually? :)
      • 2006-08-04 21628, 2006

      • luks
        typed
      • 2006-08-04 21632, 2006

      • deadchip
        well i was not able to copy it out of ethereal
      • 2006-08-04 21658, 2006

      • deadchip
        no i pasted.. with my fingers.. from ethereal
      • 2006-08-04 21657, 2006

      • luks
        so it doesn't return any xml?
      • 2006-08-04 21620, 2006

      • deadchip
        nope
      • 2006-08-04 21622, 2006

      • deadchip
        i'm trying again
      • 2006-08-04 21646, 2006

      • deadchip
        now it did
      • 2006-08-04 21656, 2006

      • deadchip
        and the response is
      • 2006-08-04 21658, 2006

      • deadchip
        lol
      • 2006-08-04 21607, 2006

      • deadchip
        <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
      • 2006-08-04 21621, 2006

      • deadchip
      • 2006-08-04 21625, 2006

      • deadchip
        </metadata>
      • 2006-08-04 21630, 2006

      • deadchip
        heh
      • 2006-08-04 21649, 2006

      • luks
        well, that means "No PUID" :)
      • 2006-08-04 21657, 2006

      • deadchip
        yeah i figure as much
      • 2006-08-04 21659, 2006

      • deadchip
        but why?
      • 2006-08-04 21602, 2006

      • luks
        can you compare the musicdns url with the other guy?
      • 2006-08-04 21616, 2006

      • deadchip
        the entire url?
      • 2006-08-04 21628, 2006

      • deadchip
        i mean
      • 2006-08-04 21635, 2006

      • deadchip
      • 2006-08-04 21636, 2006

      • luks
        only the "fpt=..." part
      • 2006-08-04 21638, 2006

      • deadchip
        the whole part
      • 2006-08-04 21639, 2006

      • deadchip
        ah
      • 2006-08-04 21641, 2006

      • deadchip
        ok
      • 2006-08-04 21603, 2006

      • luks
        that's the actuall fingerprint
      • 2006-08-04 21612, 2006

      • luks
        if it's different then libofa is doing something wrong
      • 2006-08-04 21632, 2006

      • deadchip
        well he's updating ports
      • 2006-08-04 21641, 2006

      • deadchip
        he can't install ethereal right now but when he's one we'll check it
      • 2006-08-04 21649, 2006

      • deadchip
        heh he said 5 mins, ok
      • 2006-08-04 21651, 2006

      • luks
        hm, you could try one of these files - http://music.predixis.com/downloads/ofasamples/in…
      • 2006-08-04 21613, 2006

      • luks
        the fingerpring for them should be eAS4eV8IndxzXF1scRhvWDMYHfAnkDDIIgRHjCdoJeAvzBPQHBhDEBpwMyAsABjwFEwPSBDoDlQLPAjoCIQIlAkkCCAIxAiwCNAJAAjACHwHnkbw1nRrEC5YGevNX9Gv7X/8l/r//4/2D/R78kP1z+nYAaP6c+l4A8vpG/Y//aQAkAC3/lv/NABD/uQA0/+T/v/+S/77/1f/O/9r/6//s//EokSwUA0kI0QBP53XMKPfK+Oj25/Wu9ZbPZ/FT7/fpBfq88g3He/Ba47nj4/Vo+d76MPYA+Wv8EP5B/lX+P/6J/hL94f1i/i/+Nv4X/mf+TO+H6yoGcALhE6dn/xcmAJ8CT/8cEBr/UOFT9pXzufoj
      • 2006-08-04 21615, 2006

      • luks
        An/479YN95nvvvDv/6QDTQCY+/H/If9M//oABgBW//T/+QAG/9YAVABAABQAXQBQAOXjkRtQGSgnPhJUoaD9MgS8CVwZhAVM95gFrA+fGjwJ7gb2FdsEERyXCQgCQP/NAcICZwD9ALgBjgHmAU0BPAFgAPABJQE5AXUBbgGCAU//5tUhIHBAPj040dArqguJCSgEWPLkABju2AhYBlnwv/52AuDuJ/7g8/r6qgIlAtMAov4xABIAXQFiAVcBBAE/AI4AQACrAL0BBwEhAUsAjAro7PpF7fhX+ewHp/eu5PD3Bvmc6Kb9zi/cy7bP5O+H/Cz5ohfaCWPjXPVr9hL83ADSAm0ATwDoAAf/XABiASIApwDCAQYBAQFqAYABKQF3EQ09Mw==
      • 2006-08-04 21617, 2006

      • luks
        eek!
      • 2006-08-04 21626, 2006

      • luks
        that was too long :)
      • 2006-08-04 21633, 2006

      • deadchip
        lool
      • 2006-08-04 21643, 2006

      • deadchip
        well i'm downloading one of them
      • 2006-08-04 21653, 2006

      • deadchip
        mm
      • 2006-08-04 21603, 2006

      • deadchip
        i take it the puid app has no debug output?
      • 2006-08-04 21606, 2006

      • deadchip adds some
      • 2006-08-04 21612, 2006

      • deadchip
        using ethereal for that kinda sucks
      • 2006-08-04 21613, 2006

      • deadchip
        LOL
      • 2006-08-04 21620, 2006

      • luks
        there is some in libtunepimp, but it's commented out :(
      • 2006-08-04 21655, 2006

      • Knio has quit