#musicbrainz

i was going to say include the category household items.. but it might be frowned upon to consider a baby a 'household item'

hm ok in the same way orgasm sounds could be instruments *g*

hehe, sometimes even an annoyingly nasty household item

gatschgatsch?

http://nawtythings.com/soundwav.html for the shepard in you all the adult sounds

she was fucked by god?

hee hee :)

maria!

guess thats a safe way when you dont remember who is doing ya

didn't know they had mics back in the pre BC years ;)

pre bc doppelmoppel ;)

nah it was lately. the new messiah will come!

will "come" indeed

or maybe it was fantasy sex and they wanted to be called god

http://nawtythings.com/sound/lotsoffarts.wav that really sounds like music

Thats the ExLax advertisement

*g*

i wouldn't take any medicine that make me die like this

can we rename [non-album tracks] to shit you found on p2p and don't have a clue ?

since thats what most people add then we dont have to admin it.. just let it fill up with crap :)

hmmm... changing every track title to include (instrumental) coudlnt we just put that as part of album title?

if it's on the cover it belongs to the track titles. otherwise to the annotation

teleGUISE: that'd look wrong in last.fm

unless there are no non-instrumental-only version

+s

[anon.] is much uglier ;)

does it stand for anonymous?

we're not last.fm-tagging-MB

and what's the difference to unknown?

i just thinking along the lines of where (feat. artist) is allowed in the album title when on all tracks ... which is kind of an odd thing because then none of the information is on the tracks

Shepard: that would also look wrong in my music player :)

I always thought it's a music database, not a tagging platform

it was one in the beginning perhaps

Shepard: what has a title todo with the music?

And oddly enough it is on the album cover image .. http://static.ideefixe.com/images/165/165398_2.jpg

annotation

indeed, it's an identifier :)

oops http://www.ideefixe.com/muzik/tanim.asp?sid=WGL...

do we know if the ability to remove data tracks before they are submitted during a freedb entry is coming soon? .. I cant remember if i or someone ever requested that as an enhancement

how should that work?

though not sure how people would know to use it since they are freedb entering a release instead of parsing

stop freedb imports completly :)

maybe something semi-auto that anything that says [data track] .. thought doesnt help all the other variations

gets removed...

never seen any data track as [data track] in freedb

hmm, i can't edit a wiki-page :(

ya know what i mean

Internal Server Error

you can if you believe in it!

DATA, Data Track

say tschakkah!

grr, now i get:

Someone else saved this page while you were editing!

it wasn't me

no, it was me

just trying to think of way of saving the thousands upon thousdands of data track removal edits & votes that are made

teleGUISE: aren't that many

stop freedb imports

fuchs: you think?

shepard well get the bill passed

remove data track are the easiest votes, they are no problem IMO

with parsing i'm done with freedb... but you know that will put a damper on new album edits.. which in way of fixing crap would be great but would put a major slow down on being complete

i was just thinking if it could be easily automated its that much better

you think too much ;)

sorry for using my brain :)

i give up http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/SpecialPurposeArtis...

and theeeeeeere we go again http://musicbrainz.org/showmod.html?modid=4364046

Laser Harp, isn't that more an unconventinal computer input device than a music instrument?

depends on how you see it

yeah it does

but it doesn't work alone, does it?

aren't synths computer input devices, too?

i mean the laser harp itself will produce no sound

dito

synths have the electronics integrated

what about the metallophone?

can we please get the metallophone

it's very important!

*g*

i had to list someone as playing vibraphone

fuchs: I see no difference

Shepard: that's why i'm asking

Shepard: a synth generates a sound, a laser harp does not

any easy possibility to filter relationship edit lookups?

i only know that a vacuume cleaner is a householding appliance and not a music instrument

guess it depends on artist intent

i'm not sure though, maybe it's like a synth and the sound generator is integrated, but wp says it needs to be attached to a synth or computer

laser harp is like a Luftgitarre (what's that in english?)

air guitar?

air guitar?

oh ;)

which is of course an instrument because I can play it!

a laserharp is more like a piano key than a proper instrument

the more i think about it the more i get the feeling that even a lot of synthesizers are no real instruments as well

.oO( "see? evil!" )

http://synergy-emusic.com/erro.html#Galvanic%20...: <- which of those are instruments?

fuchs: only the mellotron. teh rest are various and sundry adapters. the adapters are not instruments

and the minimoog at the top of course ;)

unfortunately moog died last year, so he can't answer the question whether his creation is an instrument or not

hey can anyone help me with this error http://pastebin.com/581184

from picard

something is really wrong with your wx

Shepard: why so adamant against the vacuum? i mean.. the guy plays it. why isn't that proof enough to be added to a list of insturments that can be used to relate to artists on MB?

i want to see him "playing" it, before i believe it ;)

it is not intended to be an instrument and it is only him

what's to see?

it's not only him

seen some pictures on rotten.com where people "played" with vacuum cleaners, but they didn't seem to make music :)

oh wow then it's 5 people on the world :)

yes, the mini-moog

i can't imaging playing a vc, so i want to see it

so what if its 5 or 2

it's an instrument

it's a householding appliance

that happens to be a musical instruemnt too

no

stop being so close minded

yes

no

yup

always 2 nos more than you :)

why do you care?

why shouldn't i?

why do you feel the need not to add it?

is a matrix printer an instrument ?

because you're close minded?

is a silo an instrument ?

okay guys your just repeating erik satie's arguments from teh 20's. using household appliances as instruments was part of theat whole Dadaism thing. move along nothing new her

"it sounds silly it can't exist"

teh vacuum cleaner is anota musical instrumnet.

"it can only serve one fuction, its can't be an instruemnt"

I know it exists, it's in the basement here

yllona: proof?

BrianG: read some dada. look up erik satie in wikipedia.

BrianG: define musical instrument :)

no ones talking abuot Dadasim