CatQuest: found 2 typos: 'saluang' and 'violin family' descriptions have </br> instead of <br/>
These have broken display on instrument list.
reosarevok is fixing them
discopatrick has quit
reosarevok
CatQuest, yvanzo: should be good now
discopatrick joined the channel
yvanzo
yes, thanks reosarevok!
JoeLlama joined the channel
JoeLlama has quit
elomatreb[m]
Hi, I'd like some advice on how I should credit works on a release that has writing credits of the form "All songs written by <Group name>; <Member A> and <Member B>"
Should I credit only to the group, only to the members, or both?
Normally I'd think crediting "as as-is as possible" would be the position, but the members are the entire lineup of the group at the time of the release so it feels pretty redundant. But I also feel like crediting to the group exclusively would also be incorrect, since the group changed members over time
reosarevok
Credit the two members at least for sure
You could add all 3 artists as well, and it wouldn't be wrong at all, but at the very least add the 2 people
CallerNo6
Would that be a good use of the "additional" flag on the "written by" rel? (for the unnamed member(s), that is)
I mean, does "additional" imply "less prominently"?
CallerNo6 has no idea
elomatreb[m]
I don't think there are any unnamed members involved here, the listed members are the entire lineup of the group at the time
On some releases they do it in the form "written by <group name>, which is <list of members>
I think I'll credit everyone, just to be on the safe side
Gazooo has quit
Freso
elomatreb[m]: Credits like that could mean that <Group name> wrote the music and {<Member A> and <Member B>} wrote the lyrics or vice versa.
elomatreb[m]
No lyrics in this case, but yeah, I thought as much
Freso
I’d probably have added <Group name>, <Member A>, and <Member B> all as "writer"s, even if that has some duplication.
Gazooo joined the channel
elomatreb[m]
Not having something like the artist credits (i.e. I can't reproduce the sentence for context) made me wonder for a bit