0:10 AM
MRiddickW joined the channel
0:14 AM
xplt has quit
1:01 AM
rdswift has quit
1:09 AM
rdswift joined the channel
1:16 AM
rdswift has quit
2:02 AM
rdswift joined the channel
2:34 AM
Vacuity joined the channel
2:37 AM
Vacuity_ has quit
3:37 AM
atsampson has quit
3:37 AM
atsampson joined the channel
4:28 AM
davic joined the channel
4:40 AM
incentive joined the channel
4:48 AM
adhi001 joined the channel
5:06 AM
Nishant-Chandla9 joined the channel
5:07 AM
Nishant-Chandla9 has quit
5:08 AM
Nishant-Chandla joined the channel
5:33 AM
Nishant-Chandla has quit
6:13 AM
culinko joined the channel
6:43 AM
griff__ joined the channel
6:53 AM
trae32566[w]-1 joined the channel
6:55 AM
trae32566[w] has quit
7:20 AM
Kevlar_Noir joined the channel
7:38 AM
jesus2099 joined the channel
7:38 AM
antlarr has quit
7:39 AM
antlarr joined the channel
8:00 AM
evelyn joined the channel
8:03 AM
GrisKo joined the channel
8:22 AM
c1e0 joined the channel
9:12 AM
griff__ has quit
9:21 AM
loujine_ is now known as loujine
9:35 AM
c1e0 has quit
9:35 AM
c1e0 joined the channel
10:19 AM
griff__ joined the channel
10:34 AM
culinko has left the channel
10:37 AM
MRiddickW has quit
10:44 AM
griff__
I have some questions about what artist(s) to add some tracks to. The tracks are from a series of movies and on the CD I am importing they are credited individually as a mix of the actors and their characters (they were child actors mostly known for just those parts). Some of the tracks already exist in MB but credited to the fictional family as a whole
https://musicbrainz.org/artist/be49ece2-ab8a-4a... one of
10:44 AM
characters Lille Per already exists in MB with song credits (the actor playing him is also in MB with no credits
https://musicbrainz.org/artist/742735d3-c984-4e... ). So do I create the missing characters credited on my CD as individual artists like discogs has done or do I credit the whole track to the fictional family like the existing tracks
10:48 AM
CatQuest
oh the song should be credited to the actual performer (we can sue artist credits too)
10:48 AM
(so for lille per I'd merg him int othe actor (but not change credits))
10:49 AM
and thne i'dd add the other performers, real names
10:49 AM
and use credits for the recordings
10:49 AM
using disambiguiations like Danish child actor / Lille Per is a good idea
10:49 AM
hah, lille per er 73 år gammel
10:51 AM
10:52 AM
thne they should be linked as "performed as" (or is ther a better rel for characters, reosarevok?)
10:52 AM
griff__
Yep. And he is mostly just known for the one role to the point that most people know who Lille Per is but not Ole Neuman
10:52 AM
CatQuest
aah
10:53 AM
i think we had a "far til fire" version in norway too 🤔
10:55 AM
oh no
10:55 AM
Det er sommer, det er sol og det er søndag
10:55 AM
griff__
The songs credited to Lille Per is only the original actor Ole Neuman
10:56 AM
CatQuest
hmm are there no other songs further?
10:56 AM
i dont know
11:11 AM
griff__
Actually I just found out they have rerecorded most of the old songs for the newer films
11:12 AM
But those are credited on Spotify to the actor not “Lille Per” which on Spotify at least is Ole Neuman
11:28 AM
How do you deal with generic artists? Like “Choir”
11:33 AM
GrisKo has quit
11:51 AM
GrisKo joined the channel
11:59 AM
otisolsen70 joined the channel
12:00 PM
otisolsen70 has quit
12:00 PM
otisolsen70 joined the channel
12:08 PM
incentive has quit
12:20 PM
otisolsen70 has quit
12:29 PM
Retr0Punk is now known as RetroPunk
12:49 PM
griff__ has quit
12:53 PM
c1e0 has quit
12:56 PM
c1e0 joined the channel
13:06 PM
srxl
Should an "acoustic version" be considered a remix of the original recording? Or is there a better relationship
13:10 PM
Cheezmo_ has quit
13:11 PM
Lotheric
13:12 PM
unless the same acapella is used of some audio is being 'recycled' into the acoustic version, I'd say it's a new recording
13:12 PM
their work might be related though
13:12 PM
srxl
yeah it's a new recording, but I'm talking about what the best recording-recording relationship between the two would be
13:12 PM
Cheezmo joined the channel
13:13 PM
yvanzo
it seems more appropriate to use recording-work relationship in this case.
13:13 PM
that is, make two recordings linked to the same work.
13:14 PM
srxl
oh that's an entity i'm not familiar with, time to hit the wiki
13:14 PM
Lotheric
That's what I was trying to tell (badly haha) ^^
13:14 PM
yvanzo
I guessed so :)
13:23 PM
adhi001 has quit
13:24 PM
srxl
Right, got my head around the work concept - now my question is, would the acoustic version be a cover recording, or just another recording?
13:25 PM
Both recording were done by the same artists
13:25 PM
griff__ joined the channel
13:28 PM
yvanzo
srxl: just another recording
13:28 PM
srxl
gotcha
13:28 PM
yvanzo
a cover recording is when the recording artist is not the original recording artist for that work.
13:29 PM
srxl
ahhhh, right
13:30 PM
Lotheric
13:30 PM
some discussion on the topic
13:31 PM
13:35 PM
yvanzo
srxl: you can mention "acoustic" in disambiguation comment/annotation.
13:35 PM
there is no relationship/attributes about it otherwise.
13:36 PM
srxl
The recording's name is "Million Days (acoustic)", so disambiguation shouldn't be necessary
13:37 PM
yvanzo
13:52 PM
otisolsen70 joined the channel
14:23 PM
griff__ has quit
14:23 PM
CatQuest
I was gonna say "yes there is!" but that's *instrumental*
14:24 PM
I guess aucustic version is more a like rerecordings
14:32 PM
adhi001 joined the channel
14:33 PM
c1e0 has quit
14:33 PM
c1e0 joined the channel
14:41 PM
c1e0 has quit
14:41 PM
c1e0 joined the channel
14:44 PM
culinko_ joined the channel
14:59 PM
culinko_ is now known as culinko
15:27 PM
Kevlar_Noir has quit
15:37 PM
c1e0 has quit
15:47 PM
phunyguy has quit
15:55 PM
finalsummer
15:55 PM
oh nevermind sorry
15:56 PM
i accidentally linked another artist with the same name
16:02 PM
GrisKo has quit
16:25 PM
c1e0 joined the channel
16:40 PM
griff__ joined the channel
16:55 PM
c1e0 has quit
16:56 PM
c1e0 joined the channel
17:07 PM
c1e0 has quit
17:10 PM
griff__ has quit
18:04 PM
Cheezmo has quit
18:05 PM
Cheezmo joined the channel
18:10 PM
Cheezmo_ joined the channel
18:14 PM
Cheezmo has quit
18:15 PM
rdswift has quit
18:28 PM
rdswift joined the channel
18:37 PM
otisolsen70 has quit
18:54 PM
tungol has quit
18:56 PM
rdswift has quit
19:05 PM
reosarevok
Forgot to say I was releasing beta, but beta released :D
19:13 PM
tungol joined the channel
19:50 PM
rdswift joined the channel
19:57 PM
tungol has quit
19:59 PM
rdswift_ joined the channel
19:59 PM
rdswift_ has quit
20:02 PM
rdswift has quit
20:02 PM
sampsyo has quit
20:06 PM
Cheezmo_ has quit
20:06 PM
rdswift joined the channel
20:06 PM
Cheezmo joined the channel
20:07 PM
sampsyo joined the channel
20:08 PM
tungol joined the channel
20:12 PM
xplt joined the channel
20:13 PM
Cheezmo_ joined the channel
20:16 PM
fannagoganna has quit
20:16 PM
Cheezmo has quit
20:23 PM
adhi001 has quit
20:38 PM
davic has quit
20:49 PM
meLon joined the channel
20:57 PM
meLon
20:57 PM
Just a heads up if those need changing or if there is a problem. I'll keep checking back no rush or anything
21:12 PM
chaban